Resolving Contradiction Among Shariah Texts Using the Approach of Abrogation  (A Comparative Fiqh-Based Fundamental Study)

Al-Azami, Lafi Muhammad Mujbil

Resolving Contradiction Among Shariah Texts Using the Approach of Abrogation (A Comparative Fiqh-Based Fundamental Study)

Document Type : Original Article

Author

Lafi Muhammad Mujbil Al-Azami

Assistant Professor at the College of Basic Education, The Public Authority for Applied Sciences

Abstract

The approach of abrogation (Naskh) in resolving the contradictory textual evidences is considered one of the most important fundamental-based topics. Fundamentalists have devoted significant attention to studying the various approaches of resolving apparent contradictions, the most prominent of which is the approach of abrogation.
The approach of abrogation adopted by scholars to resolve apparent contradictions has conditions, types, and methods for its validation, and it is applied when there are Shariah textual evidences that seem contradictory at face value. This approach has connections to various fundamental Fiqh-based topics, such as the practices of the people of Medina, the narrator’s contradiction of his own narration, and disregarding the individually reported tradition due to widespread affliction (Umum Al-Balwa).
This approach has numerous applications in various Fiqh branches, and it has been a primary reason for disagreements among Fiqh scholars. The Hanafites considered it the primary approach for clearing and resolving apparent contradictions among Shariah textual evidences.

Keywords

Main Subjects

أصول الفقه

References

- al'iitqan fi eulum alqurani, altaalifi: eabd alrahman bin 'abi bakr, jalal aldiyn alsuyuti, almuhaqaqa: muhamad 'abu alfadl 'iibrahim, alhayyat almisriat aleamat lilkitabi, du.ti, 1394hi- 1974m.

- 'iihkam alfusul fi al'asla, talifu: 'abi alwalid sulayman bin khalaf albaji, muasasat alrisalati- bayrut, ta1, 1409hi- 1989m.

- al'ahkam fi 'usul aldalili, altaalifi: 'abi alhasan aldiyn sayid eali bin 'abi eali bin muhamad bin salim alkharifi alamdi, almuhaqiqa: eabd alrazaaq eafifi, almaktab al'iislamiu- bayrut, du.ta, da.t.

- al'iihkam fi 'usul al'ahkami, talifu: 'abi muhamad eali bin 'ahmad bin saeid bin hazm al'andalsi alqurtubii alzaahiri, almuhaqaqi: alshaykh 'ahmad muhamad shakiri, dar alafaq aljadidati- bayrut, du.ta, da.t.

- aikhtilaf alhadithi, talifu: muhamad bin 'iidris alshaafieii, almuhaqaqi: muhamad 'ahmad eabd aleaziza, dar alkutub aleilmiati- bayrut , ta1, 1406hi- 1986m.

- 'iirshad alfuhul 'iilaa tahqiq alhaqi min eilm al'usulu, talifu: muhamad bin eali bin muhamad bin eabd allah alyamanii alshshwkani, almuhaqaqi: alshaykh 'ahmad eazw einayata, dar alkitaab alearabii- dimashqa, ta1, 1419hi- 1999m.

- 'usul alsarakhisi, talifu: 'abi bakr muhamad alsarukhsi, dar almaerifati- bayrut, du.ta, du. t.

- 'usul alfiqh al'iislamii, talifu: da.whbat alzuhayli, dar alfikri, ta1, 1406h- 1986m.

- 'usul alfiqh, talifu: muhamad 'abu alnuwr zuhayr, almaktabat al'azhariat liltarathi, du.ta, da.t.

- 'usul alfiqh, talifu: muhamad 'abu zahrata, dar alfikri, du.ti, da.t.

- alaietibar fi alnaasikh walmansukh min alathar, talifu: 'abi bakr muhamad bin musaa bin euthman alhazimii alhamdani, dayirat almaearif aleuthmaniati- hidrabad aldakn, ta2, 1359hi.

- al'um, talifu: alshaafieii 'abi eabd allh muhamad bin 'iidris, dar almaerifati- bayrut, du.ti, 1410hi- 1990m.

- albahr almuhit fi 'usul alfiqh, talifu: 'abi eabd allah badr aldiyn muhamad bin eabd allh bin bihadir alzarkashi, dar alkatbi, ta1, 1414hi- 1994m.

- alburhan fi 'usul alfiqh, talifu: eabd almalik bin eabd alllh bin yusif bin muhamad aljuayni, 'abi almaeali, rukn aldiyn, almulaqab bi'iimam alharamayni, almuhaqaqa: salah bin muhamad bin euaydita, dar alkutub aleilmiati- bayrut, ta1, 1418hi- 1997m.

- alburhan fi eulum alqurani, talifu: 'abi eabd allah badr aldiyn muhamad bin eabd allah bin bhadir alzarkashi, almuhaqaqa: muhamad 'abu alfadl 'iibrahim, dar almaerifati- bayrut, ta1, 1376hi- 1957m.

- tafsir alquran aleazimi= tafsir abn kathirin, talifu: 'iismaeil bin eumar abn kathirin, almuhaqiqa: sami alsalamati, dar tiibati, ta2, 1420h- 1999m.

- altamhid lima fi almuataa min almaeani wal'asanidi, talifu: 'abi eumar yusif bin eabd allah bin muhamad bin eabd albur, almuhaqaqi: mustafaa bin 'ahmad alealawi, muhamad eabd alkabir albikri, wizarat eumum al'awqaf walshuwuwn al'iislamiati- almaghrbi, du.ti, 1387h.

- taysir altahriri, talifu: muhamad 'amin almaeruf bi'amir badshah, dar alfikri- bayrut, du.ta, da.t.

- jamie albayan fi tawil ay alquran= tafsir altabri, talifu: muhamad bin jarir altabari, almuhaqiqu: da.eabd allah alturkiu bialtaeawun mae markaz albuhuth bidar hijar, hajr liltibaeat walnashri- alqahirati, ta1, 1422h- 2001m.

- rudat alnaazir wajnat almanazir fi 'usul alfiqh, talifu: 'abi muhamad muafaq aldiyn eabd allah bin 'ahmad bin muhamad bin qudamat almaqdisi, alryan liltibaeati- alqahirati, bayrut, ta2, 1423hi- 2002m.

- sunan altirmidhii (aljamie alsahihu), talifu: muhamad bin eisaa altirmidhi, dar alkutub aleilmiati- bayrut, du.ti, 1403hi.

- sharah alkawkab almunir, talifu: muhamad bin 'ahmad alfutuhii alhanbalii almaeruf biabn alnijar, almuhaqaqa: muhamad alzuhaylii wada.nzih hamad, maktabat aleabikan- alrayad, ta2, 1418hi- 1997m.

- sharh allamea, talifu: 'abi 'iishaq 'iibrahim alshiyrazi, almuhaqiqa: eabd almajid turki, dar algharb al'iislami, ta1, 1408h- 1988m.

- sharh almanar wahawashih min eilm al'usul ealaa matn almanar lilnisfi, talifu: eiz aldiyn eabd allatif bin eabd aleaziz bin malik, dur saeadt (matbaeat euthmania), du.ti, 1315h.

- sharh mukhtasar alrawdata, talifi: sulayman bin eabd alqawii altuwfiu, almuhaqiqa: eabd alllh bin eabd almuhsin alturki, muasasat alrisalati, ta1, 1407h- 1987m.

- sharh mukhtasar almunari, talifi: mulla eali alqari, du.t

- sharh mukhtasar almuntahaa al'usulii lil'iimam 'abi eamrw euthman aibn alhajib almaliki, talifu: eudd aldiyn eabd alrahman al'iiji, dar alkutub aleilmiati, bayrut - lubnan, ta1, 1424ha- 2004m.

- sharh maeani alathar, talifu: 'abi jaefar 'ahmad bin muhamad bin salamat bin eabd almalik bin salamat al'azdi alhajarii almisriu almaeruf bialtahawi, almuhaqaqa: muhamad zahri alnajar- muhamad sayid jad alhaq, ealam alkatab, ta1, 1414hi- 1994m.

- shih albukhari, talifu: muhamad bin 'iismaeil 'abi eabd allah albukharii aljaeafi, almuhaqaqa: muhamad zuhayr bin nasir alnaasir, dar tawq alnajaa (msawarat ean alsultaniat bi'iidafat tarqim tarqim muhamad fuad eabd albaqi), ta1, 1422h.

- shih muslma, talifi: muslim bin alhajaaj 'abi alhasan alqushayri alniysaburi, almuhaqaqa: muhamad fuad eabd albaqi, dar 'iihya' alturath alearabi- bayrut, du.ti, da.t.

- aleidat fi 'usul alfiqh, talifi: alqadi 'abi yaelaa, muhamad bin alhusayn bin muhamad bin khalaf aibn alfara', almuhaqiqi: da.'ahmad bin ealiin bin sir almubarki, da.n, ta2, 1410hi- 1990m.

- ealam 'usul alfiqah, talifu: eabd alwahaab khllaf, maktabat aldaewa (ean altabeat althaaminat lidar alqilm), du.ti, da.t.

- eumdat alqariy sharh sahih albukhari, talifu: 'abi muhamad mahmud bin 'ahmad bin musaa bin 'ahmad bin husayn alghitabi alhanafii badr aldiyn aleayni, dar 'iihya' alturath alearabi- bayrut, du.ta, da.t.

- fath albari sharh sahih albukhari, talifu: 'ahmad bin ealiin bin hajar 'abi alfadl aleasqalaniu alshaafieii, dar almaerifat - bayrut, du.ti, 1379h.

- fath alqudir, talifu: kamal aldiyn muhamad bin eabd alwahid alsiyuasi almaeruf biabn alhamami, dar alfikri, du.ti, da.t.

- fath almughith bisharh 'alfiat alhadith lileiraqi, talifu: shams aldiyn 'abi alkhayr muhamad bin eabd alrahman bin muhamad bin 'abi bakr bin euthman bin muhamad alsakhawi, almuhaqaq: eali husayn ealay, maktabat alsanati- masr, ta1, 1424h- 2003m.

- fath bab aleinayat bisharh alnnuqayt, talifi: nur aldiyn 'abi alhasan eali bin sultan muhamad alharawi alqariy, almuhaqaqa: muhamad nizar timim, haytham nizar timim, dar al'arqam bin 'abi al'arqamu- bayrut, ta1, 1418hi- 1997m.

- fawatih alrahmut bisharh muslim althubuti, talifu: almuhibi albahari, dar alkutub aleilmiati- bayrut, ta1, 1423h- 2002m.

- qawatie al'adilat fi al'usulu, talifu: 'abi almuzafar, mansur bin muhamad alsimeani altamimi alhanafiu thuma alshaafieii, almuhaqaqa: muhamad hasan muhamad hasan aismaeil alshaafieii, dar alkutub aleilmiati, bayrut, lubnan, ta1, 1418h- 1999m.

- kashf al'asrar sharh 'usul albizdiwi, talifu: eala' aldiyn albukharia, dar alkitaab al'iislamii, du.ta, da.t.

- kashf al'asrar, talifu: 'abi albarakat eabd allh bin 'ahmad alnusafi, dar alkutub aleilmiati- bayrut, du.ti, di.t.

- lisan alearabi, talifu: muhamad bin makram abn manzura, dar sadir- bayrut, ta3, 1414h.

- allamae fi 'usul alfiqah, matbue mae takhrij 'ahadith allamea, talifu: 'abi 'iishaq 'iibrahim alfiruzabadi alshiyrazi, ealim alkatab, ta2, 1406hi- 1986m.

- almabsuta, talifu: muhamad bin 'ahmad bin 'abi sahl shams al'ayimat alsarukhsii, dar almaerifati- bayrut, du.ti, 1414hi- 1993m.

- almahsuli, talifu: 'abi eabd allah muhamad bin eumar bin alhasan bin alhusayn altaymi alraazi almulaqab bifakhr aldiyn alraazi, almuhaqiqi: alduktur tah jabir fayaad aleilwani, muasasat alrisalati, ta3, 1418hi- 1997m.

- mukhtalif alhadith eind al'iimam abn eabd albur- erdan wadirasatu, talifi: eabd allh bin jabir alhamaadii, dar kinz 'iishbilya lilnashr waltawzie- alrayad, ta1, 1433h.

- mudhakirat fi 'usul alfiqh, talifu: muhamad al'amin bin muhamad almukhtar bin eabd alqadir aljakniu alshanqiti, maktabat aleulum walhikmi, almadinat almunawarati, ta5, 2001m.

- almustasfaa, talifu: 'abi hamid muhamad bin muhamad altuwsii alghazaliu, almuhaqaqa: muhamad eabd alsalam eabd alshaafi, dar alkutub aleilmiati, ta1, 1413hi- 1993m.

- maslim althubuti, matbue mae almustasfaa lilghazalii, talifu: muhibi allah bin eabd alshukur, dar sadr- birut, 1119hi.

- maealim 'usul alfiqh eind 'ahl alsunat waljamaeati, talifu: muhamad bin husayn aljizani, dar aibn aljuzi, ta5, 1427h.

- muejam maqayis allughati, talifu: 'abi alhusayn bin faris bin zakaria, almuhaqiqa: eabdalsalam harun, dar 'iihya' alkutub alearabiati- alqahirati, ta1, 1368h.

- maerifat 'anwae eulum alhaditha, wyuerf bimuqadimat aibn alsalahi, talifu: euthman bin eabd alrahman, 'abi eamrw, taqi aldiyn almaeruf biaibn alsalahi, almuhaqaqi: nur aldiyn eatra, dar alfikri- suria, dar alfikr almueasiri- bayrut, du.ti, 1406hi- 1986m.

- manahil aleirfan fi eulum alqurani, talifi: muhamad eabd aleazim alzzurqany, matbaeat eisaa albabi alhalabi washarakahi, ta3, da.t.

- manhaj al'iimam altahawi fi dafe altaearud bayn alnusus alshareiat min khilal kitabih <>, talifi: hasan eabd alhamid bin eabd alhakim bikhari, risala majistir fi 'usul alfiqh al'iislamii, kuliyat alsharieat waldirasat al'iislamiati- jamieat 'um alquraa- almamlakat alearabiat alsueudiat, 1422hi.

- manhaj altawfiq waltarjih bayn mukhtalif alhadith wa'atharih fi alfiqh al'iislami, talifu: eabd almajid muhamad alsawsuat, dar alnafayisi, du.ta, da.t.

- almuhadhab fi eilm 'usul alfiqh almuqarani, talifu: eabd alkarim bin ealiin bin muhamad alnamlata, maktabat alrushdi- alrayad, ta1, 1420hi-1999m.

- almuafaqati, talifa: 'iibrahim bin musaa bin muhamad allakhmi algharnatii alshaatibiu, almuhaqaqa: 'abu eubaydat mashhur bin hasan al silman, dar abn eafan, ta1, 1417hi- 1997m.

- nuzhat alkhatir aleatiri, talifu: eabd alqadir bin 'ahmad bin mustafaa badran aldimashqi, dar alhadithi- bayrut, maktabat alhudaa- ras alkhaymati, ta1, 1412h- 1991m.

- nihayat alwusul fi dirayat al'usul, talifu: sifay aldiyn muhamad bin eabd alrahim al'armawi alhindiu, almuhaqiqa: da.salih bin sulayman alyusif- da.saed bin salim alsuwih, 'asl altahqiqi: risalata dukturah bijamieat al'iimam bialriyad, almaktabat altijariat bimakat almukaramati, ta1, 1416h- 1996m.

- nawasikh alquran = nasikh alquran wamansukhuhu, talifu: jamal aldiyn 'abi alfaraj eabd alrahman bin eali bin muhamad aljuzi, almuhaqiqa: 'abu eabd allah aleamili alssalfy aldaani bin munir al zahwi, sharikat 'abna' sharif al'ansari- bayrut, ta1, 1422hi- 2001m.

- alwadih fi 'usul alfiqh, talifu: eali bin eaqil bin muhamad bin eaqil albaghdadi alzafri, 'abi alwafa', almuhaqiqi: alduktur eabd allah bin eabd almuhsin alturki, alrisalatu- bayrut, ta1, 1420hi- 1999m.