Imam al-Busiri's Critiques (died in 840 AH)) in His Book " Ithaf al-Khiyara al-Mahra with the Additions of the Ten Musanads"" on Al-hafez Al-Monzeri (died in 656 AH) -A Critical Hadith Study –

Document Type : Original Article

Author

Department of Hadith and its Sciences, College of Islamic and Arabic Studies for Girls Al-Quarin Sharqiyah - Al-Azhar University – Egypt

Abstract

This research was concerned with studying the Critiques made by Imam Al-Busairi (d. 840 AH) in his book entitled: “Ithaf Al-Khiyara Al-Mahra with the Additions of the Ten Musanads”: on Al-Hafez Al-Monzeri (d. 656 AH); a critical scientific study according to the methodology and rules of the scholars in this field, trying to find the rightness of them. In this research, I have explained the meaning of Critiques linguistically and technically, as well as the origins and importance of Critiques. Then I mentioned a brief biography of both of the Imams Al -Hafez Al-Monzeri and Al-Busiri - may Allah have mercy on them – and I introduced the book “Ithaf Al-Khaira Al-Mahra”. After reviewing the entire book, I extracted the Critiques of Imam Al-Busiri on Al-Hafez Al-Monzeri, which reached nine Critiques, which I studied and edited the arguments in them. This is the core of the research and its purpose. so this study was based on the method of induction, analysis, and criticism. this study reached a number of results, The most important of which are: diversity of Critiques between those related to men, such as an unknown narrator, as in the first and ninth Critique. (or weak: as in the third and seventh Critiques), and illusions in

Keywords

Main Subjects


  1. 'iithaf alkhayarat almuharat bizawayid almasanid aleashrati: almualafi: 'ahmad bin albusiri. dar alwatani, ta1, alrayad, 1420 hu
  2. aliastieab fi maerifat al'ashabi, bin eabd albur, tahqiq ealaa albajawi, maktabat nahdat misr bialqahirati, 1380 h
  3. 'asad alghabat fi maerifat alsahabati, eizi aldiyn abn al'athira, dar alkutub aleilmiati, bayrut. ta1, 1415h..
  4. al'iisabat fi tamyiz alsahabati, 'ahmad bin ealiin bin hajara, dar alkutub aleilmiat - bayrut, ta1 - 1415 hi.
  5. al'aealami, khayr aldiyn alzarkili, dar aleilm lilmalayini, ta15 - mayu 2002 m
  6. 'iikmal tahdhib alkamal fi 'asma' alrijal: eala' aldiyn mughaltay bin qalija, tahqiqa: muhamad euthman, dar alkutub aleilmiati, bayrut, ta1, 2011 mi.
  7. 'iinba' alghamar bi'abna' aleumra, abn hajr, tahqiqi: du. muhamad almueidi, ta2, bayrut, dar alkutub aleilmiati, 1406 hi.
  8. al'ansab, eabd alkarim alsimeani, majlis dayirat almaearif aleuthmaniati, haydar abad aldukn - alhinda, ta1, 1382 h
  9. albidayat walnihayatu, 'abu alfida'i, 'iismaeil bin kathirin, tahqiqu: da. eabd allah alturki, dar hajr liltibaeati, ta1, 1420h
  10. baghyat albahith ean zawayid musnad alharthi, nur aldiyn alhaythami, tahqiqu: da. husayn albakri, ta1, almadinat alnabawiat, markaz khidmat alsanat , 1413h.
  11. taj alearus min jawahir alqamus, mhmmd alzzabydy, tahqiqu: jamaeat min almukhtasiyna, dar 'iihya'in,
  12. tarikh 'asma' althaqati. aibn shahin. tahqiqu: subhi alsaamaraayiy. aldaar alsalafiat - alkuaytu. ta1, 1404 h
  13. tarikh al'iislam wawafyat almashahir walaelam, aldhahbi. tahqiqu: bashaar ewwad, dar algharb al'iislami, ta1, 2003 mi.
  14. altaarikh alkabira, muhamad bin 'iismaeil albukhari, tahqiqu: muhamad bin salihi, almutamayiz liltibaeati, alrayad. ta1, 1440
  15. tarikh baghdad wadhuyuluhu, lilkhatib albaghdadii, dar alkutub aleilmiati, bayrut, tahqiqu: mustafaa eataa, ta1, 1417 ha.
  16. altaarikh ean 'abi zakariaa yahyaa bin mueayan - riwayat aldawrii eanhu, tahqiqu: 'ahmad sifi. markaz albahth aleilmii wa'iihya' alturath - makat almukaramatu. ta1, 1399 hu
  17. tarikh madinat dimashqa, ealiin bin alhasan abn easakri, tahqiqa: eamru aleumrawi. dar alfikri, 1415 hi.
  18. tadhkirat alhafazi, aldhahabi, dar alkutub aleilmiat bayrut-t 1, 1419hi.
  19. altarghib waltarhib min alhadith alsharifi, eabd aleazim almundhiri, tahqiqu: 'iibrahim shams aldiyn, dar alkutub aleilmiat - bayrut. ta1, 1417h
  20. altaerifati, ealaa aljirjani, tahqiqu: jamaeat min aleulama'i, dar alkutub aleilmiat bayrut, ta1, 1403h
  21. taqrib altahdhibi, 'ahmad bin ealii bin hajara, tahqiqu: muhhamd eawaamatu, dar alrashid - surya, ta1, 1406..
  22. altakmilat lufiat alnaqlati, eabd aleazim almundhiri, tahqiqu: bashaar eawad, muasasat alrisalati, ta2, 1401 hu
  23. altamyizi, muslim bin alhajaji, tahqiqu: muhamad mustafaa al'aezami, maktabat alkawthar, alsueudiati, ta3, 1410 h
  24. tahadhib altahdhibi, abn hajar, biaetina'i: 'iibrahim alziybqa, eadil murshid. muasasat alrisalat - bayrut. ta1, 1435 hu
  25. tahadhib alkamal fi 'asma' alrijali, yusif almazi, tahqiqu: bashaar eawad, alrisalat - bayrut. ta1, 1400 hu.
  26. tahadhib allughati, muhamad al'azharii alhuruii, tahqiqu: muhamad eawad, dar 'iihya' alturath - bayrut. ta1, 2001m.
  27. althiqat miman lam yaqae fi alkutub alsitatu. bn qutlubagha , tahqiqu: shadi al nueman. markaz alnueman lilbuhuthi, sanea', alyaman. ta1, 1432 hu .
  28. althiqati: muhhamd bin hibaan, muraqibatu: du. muhmmad eabdalmueidi, dayirat almaearif aleuthmaniati, alhindi, ta1, 1393 h
  29. jamie altahsil fi 'ahkam almarasili, salah aldiyn alealayiy, tahqiqu: hamdi alsalafi, ealim alkutub - bayrut, ta2, 1407 h
  30. jamie alsanan, 'abu eabd allah muhamad yazid abn majah ti: muhamad fuaad eabd albaqi, dar 'iihya' alkutub alearabiati.
  31. aljamie alsahih - sahih muslimi-, muslim bin alhajaji, tahqiqa: muhamad dhihni wakhrun, tawq alnajaat - bayrut,
  32. aljamie alkabir - sunan altirmidhi, muhamad bin eisaa, tahqiqu: bashaar eawadi, dar algharb al'iislamii, bayrut. ta1, 1996
  33. aljamie almusnad alsahihu, muhamad bin 'iismaeil albukhariu, dar altaasil - alqahiratu. ta1, 1433 hi.
  34. aljurh waltaedili: eabd alrahman bin 'abi hatim alraazi, dayirat almaearif aleuthmaniati, alhinda. ta1, 1271 hi.
  35. hilyat al'awlia'i: 'abu naeim, birut, dar bayrut, 1405 h
  36. sinan 'abi dawud, sulayman bn al'asheatha, tahqiqu:al'arnawuwt - mhammad kamil qarah , dar alrisalati, ta1, 1430 hi .
  37. sunan altirmidhi, muhamad bin eisaa, tahqiqu: 'ahmad shakir, matbaeat mustafaa alhalbi, masr, ta2, 1395 hu.
  38. sunan aldaariqatani, 'abu alhasan aldaariqatani, tahqiqu: shueayb aliarnuuwt, wakhrun, muasasat alrisalati, ta1, 1424
  39. alsunan alsaghir lilbihaqi, 'ahmad bin alhusayn albayhaqi, tahqiqu: eabd almueti 'amin qileiji. jamieat aldirasat al'iislamiati, karatshi ta1, 1410h
  40. alsunan alkubraa, 'ahmad bin shueayb alnisayiyu tahqiqu: hasan eabd almuneim shalabi, muasasat alrisalati, ta1, 1421 hu
  41. alsunan alkabira, 'ahmad albayhaqi, tahqiqu: eabd allah alturki, markaz hajr lilbuhuthi, alqahirati, ta1, 1432 hu
  42. sir 'aelam alnubala'i., 'ahmad bin euthman aldhahabi, tahqiq jamaeati, muasasat alrisalati. ta3, 1405 hu
  43. shadharat aldhahab fi 'akhbar min dhahabi., aibn aleimad aleakry alhanbali, tahqiqu: mahmud al'arnawuwta. , dar aibn kathir, dimashq - bayrut. ta1, 1406 h:
  44. alsihah taj allughat wasihah alearabiat: 'abu nasr aljawhari, tahqiqu: 'ahmad eatar, dar aleilmi- bayrut, ta4, 1407
  45. sahih abn khuzaymata, muhamad bn 'iishaq, tahqiqu: muhamad mustafaa al'aezami, almaktab al'iislamiu - bayrut.
  46. sahih muslamin, muslim bin alhajaji, tahqiqu: muhamad fuaad eabd albaqi, dar 'iihya' altarathi, bibayrut, 1374 hu
  47. silat altakmilat lufyat alnuqlati, eiz aldiyn alhusayni, tahqiqu: bashaar eawadi, dar algharb , bayrut, ta1, 1428 hu
  48. sianat sahih muslma, aibn alsalahi, tahqiqu: muafaq eabd alqadir, dar algharb al'iislamii, bayrut, ta2, 1408h
  49. aldueafa' alkabira, muhamad bin eamrw aleaqili, tahqiqu: eabd almueti qaleaji, ta1, bayrut, dar almaktabat aleilmiati, 1404 hu
  50. aldueafa' walmatrukuna, alnasayiy, tahqiqu: mahmud zayid, ta1, dar alwaei, 1396h
  51. aldaw' allaamie li'ahl alqarn altaasie, muhamad bin eabd alrahman alsakhawii bayrut, dar maktabat alhayati,
  52. tabaqat alhanabilati, bin 'abi yaelaa, matbaeat alsunat almuhamadiat - alqahiratu., 1371 hu
  53. tabaqat alshaafieiat alkubraa, alsabki, tahqiqu: mahmud altanahi,hijr liltibaeat walnashr waltawziei, ta2, 1413h
  54. tabaqat alshaafieiiyna, 'abu alfida' 'iismaeil kathir alqurashi, tahqiqu: d 'ahmad eumar hashim, d muhamad zayanuhum muhamad eazba, maktabat althaqafat aldiyniati, 1413 hu
  55. altabaqat alkubraa. almualafu: muhamad bin saedi, tahqiqu: muhamad eataa. dar alkutub aleilmiat - bayrut. ta1, 1410 hu
  56. ealal altirmidhii alkabiri, 'abutalib alqadi, tahqiqu: subhi alsaamaraayiy, wazumalawuhu, ta1, bayrut, ealam alkatub, 1409h
  57. ealal alhadithi, eabd alrahman bin 'abi hatim, tahqiqa: fariq min albahithina, ta1, alriyad, matabie alhumaydi, 1427h
  58. aleilal wamaerifat alrijali, biriwayat eabd allahi, bin hanbal, tahqiqu: wasiyu allh eabaasa. dar alkhani, alrayad. ta2, 1422
  59. fath albari bisharh albukharii. 'ahmad bin ealiin bin hajara, du.t dar almaerifat -birut,1379 hi.
  60. alqabs fi sharh muataa malik bin 'ansa, 'abu bakr bin alearabii, tahqiqu: muhamad wilid kirim, dar algharba, ta1, 1992
  61. alkashif fi maerifat man lah riwayat fi alkutub alsitatu: aldhahabi, tahqiqu: muhamad eawaamat, ta1, jidat, dar alqiblati, 1413
  62. alkamil fi dueafa' alrijal, eabd allah bin eudi, tahqiqu: habib alrahman, ta1, bayrut, alrisalati, 1399h
  63. ktab aleayni, alkhalil bin 'ahmad alfarahidii , tahqiqu: mahdii almakhzumi, dar w maktabat alhilal.
  64. alkitaab almusanaf fi al'ahadith waluathar, 'abi shibata, tahqiqu: kamal alhuti, maktabat alrushdi, alrayad, ta1, 1409h
  65. kashf al'astar ean zawayid albazaar, alhaythami, tahqiqa: habib alrahman al'aezami, ta1, bayrut, muasasat alrisalati, bayrut, ta1, 1399 hu
  66. alkifayat fi eilm alriwayati. 'ahmad alkhatib albaghdadii, jameiat dayirat almaearif aleuthmaniati, alhindi, ta1, 1357 hi.
  67. alkamal fi 'asma' alrijal, eabd alghanii almaqdisi, tahqiqu: shadi al nueman, sharikat ghras, alkuayti, ta1, 1437
  68. alkunaa wal'asma'i. muslim bin alhajaji. tahqiqa: alqushqarii. aljamieat al'iislamiatu, almadinat almunawarati. ta1, 1404 hu
  69. alkunaa wal'asma'i, muhamad bin 'ahmad alduwlabi, tahqiqa: nazar alfaryabi, ta1, bayrut, dar abn hazma, 1421h
  70. lab allibab fi tahrir al'ansab. alsuyuti, dar sadir - bayrut.
  71. lisan alearabi, abn manzuri, dar sadir - bayrut, ta3 - 1414 hu
  72. lisan almizani, bin hajar, muasasat al'aelami , bayrut, ta2, 1390h
  73. almujtabaa, alnasayiy, ta2, halaba, maktabat almatbueat al'iislamiati, 1406 h
  74. almajruhina, bin hiban, tahqiqu: mahmud 'iibrahim, ta1, halba, dar alwaei, 1396h
  75. mujmae alzawayid wamanbae alfawayidi, ealiu bin 'abi bakr alhaythami, ta8, bayrut, dar alkutub aleilmiati, 1408h
  76. almuhalaa bialathar: ealiin bin 'ahmad bin hazm al'andalusii , dar alfikr - bayrut.
  77. almukhtaratu, muhamad bin eabd alwahid aldiya' almiqdisi, tahqiqu: eabd almalik bin dahiish, ta4, bayrut, dar khadar, 1420h
  78. almustadrik ealaa alsahihayni, alhakimi, tahqiqu: eabd alqadir eataa, bayrut, dar alkutub aleilmiati, 1411h
  79. musnad 'abi hanifat riwayat alhasakafi, alnueman bin thabita, tahqiqu: eabd alrahman mahmud, aladab - misr
  80. msnad 'abi dawud altiyalsi, sulayman bin dawud, tahqiqu: muhamad alturki, dar hijr - misr ta1, 1419 hu
  81. musnad albazaar, 'ahmad bin eamrw albazaar, tahqiqu: mahfaz alrahman, ta1, almadinati, maktabat aleulum walhikmi, 2009m.
  82. msnid alshaamiin, sulayman bin 'ahmada, tahqiqu: hamdi alsalafi, muasasat alrisalat - bayrut, ta1, 1405 h
  83. almusandi, 'ahmad bin hanbal, tahqiqa: al'arnawuwt, wakhrun, muasasat alrisalati, ta1, 1421h
  84. almusandi, 'ahmad bin eali 'abu yaelaa, tahqiqu: saeid bin muhamad alsanari, dar alhadith - alqahirati. ta1, 1434 hu
  85. almusandi, altiyalsi, ti: muhamad alturkiu, ta1, masr, dar hijr, 1419 hu
  86. almusanafi, eabd allah bin 'abi shibat, tahqiqu: kamal yusuf alhuta, ta1, alriyad, maktabat alrushdi, 1409h
  87. almatalib alealiat bizawayid almasanid althamaniati, bin hajara, dar aleasimati, alsueudiati. ta1, 1419h.:
  88. almuejam al'awsatu, altabrani, tahqiqu: tariq eawad allah, ta1, alqahirata, dar alharmayni, 1415h
  89. muejam albildan, yaqut alhamawi, dar sadir, birut, ta2, 1995 mi.
  90. almuejam alkabira, sulayman altabrani, tahqiqu: hamdi alsalafi, ta2, alqahirata, dar maktabat abn taymiati, 1415h
  91. maejam lughat alfuqaha'i, muhamad rawaas qaleaji - hamid sadiq qanibi, dar alnafayis liltibaeati, ta2, 1408 hu
  92. muejam maqayis allughati, 'ahmad bin faris, tahqiq eabd alsalam harun, ta1, birut, dar alfikri, 1399 hu
  93. maerifat althiqati, aleajlaa, tahqiqu: eabd alealim albustui, ta1, almadinat almunawarati, maktabat aldaar 1405h
  94. maerifat alrijal ean yahyaa bin muein, tahqiqu: majmueati, majmae allughat alearabiat - dimashqa. ta1, 1405h
  95. almaerifat waltaarikhu, alfuswi, tahqiq aleumri. matbaeat al'iirshad - baghdadu.
  96. almuelam bishuyukh albukharii wamuslma, bin khalfwn tahqiq eadil saeda. dar alkutub aleilmiat - bayrut
  97. almughaniy fi aldueafa'i, aldhahabi, tahqiqu: alduktur nur aldiyn eatr
  98. almaqsid alealii fi zawayid 'abi yaelaa almusli": alhaythami, tahqiqu: sayid kasarawi hasan, bayrut, dar alkutub aleilmiati.
  99. mizan alaietidal fi naqd alrajal, aldhahabi, tahqiqu: eali muhamad albijawi, dar almaerifati, bayrut, ta1, 1382 hu
  100. nasb alraayat li'ahadith alhidayati, alziylei, tahqiqu: muhamad eawaamatu, dar alqiblat - jidat -, ta1, 1418hi.
  101. alnukt albadieat ealaa almawdueati, alsuyutii tahqiqu: eabd allah shaeban, dar makata, ta1, 1425