Contraposition according to Najmuddin Al-Katibi from criticism to documenting A comparative analytical study

Rabie, Raed Abdel Gawad Ali

doi:10.21608/bfda.2024.384296

Contraposition according to Najmuddin Al-Katibi from criticism to documenting A comparative analytical study

Author

Raed Abdel Gawad Ali Rabie

Department of Theology & Philosophy, Faculty of Theology & Islamic Da‘wah in Tanta, Alazhar University, Arabic Republic of Egypt.

10.21608/bfda.2024.384296

Abstract

This research aims to achieve several objectives, most notably: to reveal Alkatibi's criticism to reverse the contradiction according to advanced Muslim scholars, to describe his opinion about this issue and to highlight the issues of disagreement between such scholars in their study to reverse the Contraposition. This research also aims to Identifying the evolution of logic according to Muslim scholars revealing their ability to analyze and adjust logical laws appropriately. Logic is a criterion for science and highlighting the impact of the Alkatibi's opinions on the late Muslim scholars about Contraposition in the case of agreement or disagreement. In this research, the analytical and comparative approach has been followed. One of the most prominent and important findings is that Al Katibi in his definition has followed his Sheikh Ether El Dien Al-Abhary. and that Al Katibi 's opinions in his books differed as to where some of the issues addressed are reflected. and, in contrast to conditional texts, the late scholars have endeavored to clarify the correctness of these differences or to interpret it in a way that omit such differences, and to say the contraposition according to Al Katibi and other late scholars after the Aristotle logic is considered a development of Aristotle logic and a proof of the ability of the Muslim scholars to innovate and innovate, and one of the most important recommendations recommended is to complete the study of Al Katibi's situation on the views of Ibn Sina about the logic issues, and to study Shams Al-Din Samarkandi's efforts to defend the contraposition of Ibn Sina and its impact on the late scholars.

Keywords

Main Subjects

العقيدة والفلسفة

References

References :

abn alfutii (kamal aldiyn eabd alrazaaq bin 'ahmad bn muhamad almaeruf biabn alfutii t 723hi)

1- majmae aladab fi muejam al'alqabi, tahqiqu: muhamad alkazim, muasasat altibaeat walnashri- wizarat althaqafat wal'iirshad al'iislami- tahran, altabeat al'uwlaa, 1416hi.

abn almutahir alhuliu (jamal aldiyn alhasan bin yusif bin ealii bin almutahir alhilii t 726hi)

2- al'iijazat alkabirat libani zahrat, dimn kitabi: bahaar al'anwar aljamieat lidarar 'akhbar al'ayimat al'athari, talifi: muhamad baqir almajlisay, muasasat 'iihya' alkutub al'iislamiati- qam- 'iiran, altabeat al'uwlaa, 1430hi.

3- alqawaeid aljaliat fi sharh alrisalat alshamsiati, muasasat alnashr al'iislami- qim, altabeat al'uwlaa, 1412hi.

abn sina ('abu ealii alhusayn bin eabd allh bin alhasan bin sina t 428hi)

4- al'iisharat waltanbihatu, tahqiqu: du/ sulayman dunya, dar almaearifi- alqahirati, altabeat althaalithati, bidun tarikhi.

5- alshifa' (almantiq 4- alqiasi), tahqiqu: saeid zayidi, rajieh waqadim lah: du/ 'iibrahim madkur, wizarat althaqafat wal'iirshad alqawmii- almuasasat almisriat aleamat liltaalif waltarjamat waltibaeat walnashri- alqahirati, 1383hi/ 1964m.

abn kamuna (ezi aldawlat saed bin mansur bin saed bin kamunat t 683hi)

6- sharh altalwihat allawhiat walearshiati, makhtut fi maktabat shahid eali basha- turkia, biraqami: (1740).

al'abhariu ('uthir aldiyn almufadal bin eumar bin almufadal al'abharii alsamarqandii t 663hi)

7- tanzil al'afkar fi taedil al'asrar, makhtut fi maktabat raghib basha- turkia, biraqami: (826/1).

8- kashf alhaqayiq fi tahrir aldaqayiqi, tahqiqu: husayn sari 'uwghli, 'iistanbul, 2001m.

9- marasid almaqasidi, tahqiqu: da/ rajih mustafaa mustafaa hilal, dar nur alyaqin- alqahirati, altabeat al'uwlaa, 1445hi/ 2024m.

al'armawii (siraj aldiyn mahmud bin 'abi bakr bin 'ahmad al'armawii t 682hi)

10- bayan alhaqi walisan alsadaqi, makhtut fi maktabat eatif 'afandi- turkia, biraqami: (1567).

albaghdadi ('iismaeil basha bin muhamad 'amin bin mir salim albabanii albaghdadii t 1339hi)

11- hadiat alearifin 'asma' almualifin wathar almusanafina, tabe bieinayat wikalat almaearif aljalilat fi matbaeatiha albahiat- 'iistanbul, 1951hi.

albandahi (fkhr aldiyn ealiin bin albadie albandahi t 657hi)

12- sharh almuqadimat fi eilm almantiqa, makhtut fi maktabat la lah li- turkia, biraqama: (2663).

albusnawi (muhamad bin musaa albusnawii alsarayiyu alshahir bighulamik t 1045hi)

13- sharh alrisalat alshamsiat fi alqawaeid almantiqiati, makhtut fi maktabat la lah li- turkia, biraqama: (2658).

altabriziu ('abu alfadayil yahyaa bin sharaf muhamad almadhhabii altabrizii t qabl 804hi)

14- almaqasid alsuniyat fi sharh alrisalat alshamsiati, makhtut fi maktabat muhamad easim bika- turkia, biraqami: (326).

altiftazani (saed aldiyn maseud bin eumar bin eabd allh altiftazaniu t 792hi)

15- sharh alshamsiat fi almantiqi, tahqiqu: jad allah basaam salih, dar alnuwr almubini- emman- al'urduni, altabeat al'uwlaa, 1432hi/ 2011m.

aljirjaniu (alsayid alsharif ealiin bin muhamad bin ealiin aljirjanii t 816hi)

16- hashiat ealaa tahrir alqawaeid almantiqiat fi sharh alrisalat alshamsiati, tashihu: muhsin bidarfar, manshurat bidar- qim, altabeat althaaniati, 1426h.

alkhuansariu (muhamad baqir bin zayn aleabidin bin jaefar almusawii alkhuansarii t 1313hi)

17- rawdat aljanaat fi 'ahwal aleulama' walsaadati, maktabat 'iismaeilyan- tahran- qum, 1390- 1392h.

alkhawanjii ('afdal aldiyn muhamad bin namur bin eabd almalik alkhawnjii t 646hi)

18- kashf al'asrar ean ghawamid al'afkar, taqdim watahqiqu: khalid alruwyhaba, muasasat pzhwhshy hakamat wafalsafat 'iiran- tahran, wamuasasat mutalaeat 'iislami danshgah azad birlin- 'almania, altabeat al'uwlaa, 1389hi/ 2010m.

aldisuqiu (muhamad bn 'ahmad bn earfat aldisuqii t 1230hi)

19- hashiat ealaa tahrir alqawaeid almantiqiat fi sharh alrisalat alshamsiati, matbaeat kurdistan aleilmiati- masir, altabeat al'uwlaa, 1327hi.

alraazi (taj aldiyn mahmud bin ealiin bin mahmud alhamsii almaeruf bitaj alraazi t 735hi)

20- almatalib alqudusiat fi sharh alrisalat alshamsiati, makhtut fi maktabat majlis alshuwraa al'iislami- 'iiran, biraqami: (8499).

alraazi (fakhr aldiyn muhamad bin eumar bin alhusayn alraazi t 606hi)

21- almulakhas fi almantiq walhikmatu, dirasat watahqiqu: da/ eabd allah muhamad 'iismaeil, wada/ 'ahmad sabir mustafaa, wada/ rajih hilal, markaz 'iihya' lilbuhuth waldirasati- alqahirati, altabeat al'uwlaa, 1442hi/ 2021m.

alraazi (qutab aldiyn muhamad bin muhamad alraazi almaeruf bialqutb altahtanii t 766hi)

22- tahrir alqawaeid almantiqiat fi sharh alrisalat alshamsiati, tashihu: muhsin bidarfar, manshurat bidar- qim, altabeat althaaniati, 1426h.

23- lawamie al'asrar fi sharh matalie al'anwari, sahhah waqadam lah waealaq ealayhi: 'abu alqasim alrahmani, muasasat pzhwhshy hakamat wafalsafat 'iiran- tahran, altabeat al'uwlaa, 1393hi.

alzirikliu (khayr aldiyn bin mahmud bin muhamad bin ealii bin faris alzariklii t 1396hi)

24- al'aelam qamus tarajim li'ashhur alrijal walnisa' min alearab walmustaeribin walmustashriqina, dar aleilm lilmalayini- bayrut- lubnan, altabeat alkhamisat eashrata, 2002m.

alsaawi (zin aldiyn eumar bn sahlan alsaawi t 540hi)

25- albasayir alnusayriat fi eilm almantiqa, taqdim wadabt wataeliqi: da/ rafiq aleajam, dar alfikr allubnani- bayrut- lubnan, altabeat al'uwlaa, 1993m.

alsamarqandi (shams aldiyn muhamad bin 'ashraf alhusaynii alsamarqandiu t bueda: 690hi)

26- aldurat albahiat fi sharh alrisalat alshamsiati, makhtut fi maktabat la lah li- turkia, biraqama: (2659).

27- sharh qistas al'afkar fi tahqiq al'asrar, makhtut fi maktabat raghib basha- turkia, biraqami: (903).

28- qistas al'afkar fi almantiqi, tashih wataqdim watahqiqu: 'asad allah falahi, muasasat pzhwhshy hakamat wafalsafat 'iiran- tahran, altabeat al'uwlaa, 1399hi.

alsinusi ('abu eabd allh muhamad bin yusif bn eumar alsanusii t 895hi)

29- sharh alsanusii ealaa mukhtasarih fi almantiqi, tashiha: muhamad salih muhamad 'akram, almatbaeat alkhayriati, 1292hi.

alsahrurdiu (shihab aldiyn yahyaa bin habash bin 'amirk alsahrurdi t 587hi)

30- altalwihatu, tarjamat watahqiqu: du/ 'ahmad kamil jihan, wada/ salih yalin, manshurat riasat jameiat almakhtutat alturkiati- 'iistanbul, altabeat al'uwlaa, 2019m.

31- almasharie walmutarahatu, tashihu: da/ maqsud muhamadi, wa'ashraf eali pwr, nashra: haqi yawran, altabeat al'uwlaa, 1385hi.

alsiyalkutiu (eabd alhakim bin shams aldiyn muhamad alsiyalkutii alhindii t 1067hi)

32- hashiat ealaa hashiat aljirjani ealaa tahrir alqawaeid almantiqiat fi sharh alrisalat alshamsiati, matbaeat kurdistan aleilmiati- masr, altabeat al'uwlaa, 1327hi.

shams aldiyn (du/ muhamad shams aldiyn 'iibrahim salim t 1413hi)

33- taysir alqawaeid almantiqiat sharh lilrisalat alshamsiati, matbaeat dar altaalifi- masira, altabeat althaalithata, 1386hi/ 1967m.

alsafadiu (slah aldiyn khalil bin 'aybik bin eabd allh alsafadii t 764hi)

34- alwafi balufyati, tahqiq waetina'a: 'ahmad al'arnawuwta, waturki mustafaa, dar 'iihya' alturath alearabii- bayrut- lubnan, altabeat al'uwlaa, 1420hi/ 2000m.

aleataar ('abu alsaeadat hasan bin muhamad aleataar t 1250hi)

35- hashiat ealaa altadhhib sharh tahdhib almantiq walkalami, matbaeat mustafaa albabi alhalabii wa'awladuhu- masr, 1355hi/ 1936m.

alkatbiu (njam aldiyn ealiin bin eumar bin ealiin alqazwinii alkatibii t 675hi)

36- bahr alfawayid fi sharh eayn alqawaeidi, makhtut dimn majmueat fi maktabat raghib basha- turkia, biraqami: (1481/3).

37- jamie aldaqayiq fi kashf alhaqayiqi, dirasatan watahqiqu: da/ eabd allah muhamad 'iismaeil, wada/ rayid eabd aljawad rabiei, ealam li'iihya' alturath walkhadamat alraqamiat- landan- masr, wadar aldiya'- alkuaytu, altabeat al'uwlaa, 1444hi/ 2023m.

38- alrisalat alshamsiat fi alqawaeid almantiqiati, taqdim watahlil wataeliq watahqiqu: du/ mahdi fadl allah, almarkaz althaqafiu alearabia- aldaar albayda'- bayrut, altabeat al'uwlaa, 1998m.

39- sharh almawadie almushkilat min alrisalat alshamsiat fi alqawaeid almantiqiati, makhtut fi maktabat fadil 'ahmad basha- turkia, biraqami: (1612/1).

40- sharh kashf al'asrar ean ghawamid al'afkari, makhtut fi maktabat jar allah- turkia, biraqami: (1418).

41- eayn alqawaeidi, tahlil watahqiqi: salman suju, risalat majstir- maehad aleulum aliajtimaeiati- jamieat 'iistanbul, 2019m.

42- almufasal fi sharh almuhasili, tahqiqu: 'a/ eabd aljabaar 'abu sininata, murajieat watadqiqu: mu/ muhamad 'akram 'abu ghush, al'aslayn lildirasat walnashra, wakalam lilbuhuth wal'iielami, bidun raqm tabe watarikhi.

43- almansis fi sharh almulakhas, makhtut fi maktabat shahid eali basha- turkia, biraqami: (1680).

kahala (eumar rida kahalat t 1408hi)

44- muejam almualifin tarajim musanafi alkutub alearabiati, muasasat alrisalati- bayruta, altabeat al'uwlaa, 1414hi/ 1993m.

alkashy (zin aldiyn eabd alrahman bin muhamad alkishii t 661hi)

45- hadayiq alhaqayiqi, makhtut fi maktabat fadil 'ahmad basha- turkia, biraqami: (864).

46- almujaz fi almantiqa, makhtut dimn majmueat fi kitabikhanih majlis shuraa mili- 'iiran, biraqami: (9463).

almahaliyu ('ahmad almahaliy)

47- tanwir almashriq sharh tahdhib almantiqa, matbaeat alsaeadati- masira, altabeat al'uwlaa, 1331hi/ 1913m.

almalwi (shihab aldiyn 'ahmad bin eabd alfataah bin yusuf almalawii t 1181hi)

48- alsharh alkabir ealaa alsilam almunwaraq fi eilm almantiqa, aetanaa bihi: hatim bin yusif almaliki, dar aldiya'i- alkuayt, altabeat al'uwlaa, 1440hi/ 2019m.

49- allali almanthurat ealaa nuzum almuajahati, dimn kitabi: risalatan fi almuajahat almantiqiati, maktab 'iihya' alturath al'iislami- mushyakhatan al'azhar alsharif, altabeat al'uwlaa, 1443hi/ 2022m.

almibdhi (hsin bin muein aldiyn almibdhi almaeruf biqadi mir t 910hi)

50- sharh alrisalat alshamsiat fi alqawaeid almantiqiati, tabeat hajariata, 1289hi.