Classification of both Sahih and the statement of which one is the precedent ( critical study )

Hanburgi, Muhammad Abdul Kreim

doi:10.21608/bfda.2023.308365

Classification of both Sahih and the statement of which one is the precedent ( critical study )

Author

Muhammad Abdul kreim Hanburgi

department of Hadith and Sciences - faculty of Sharia and religion sciences - section of Sciences of religion - Nagran University - kingdom of Saudi Arabia

10.21608/bfda.2023.308365

Abstract

this study is tackling the classification of Sahih of Imam Bukhari and Sahih of Imam Moslem and the statement of which one is the precedent in classification in Sahih
the researcher has used the descriptive historical and analytical curriculum to analyze the statement and the text to reach of the result of the research so, the research has summarized in some results the most of the important of them is that Sahih Imam Bukhari is the precedent from imam Moslem to collect the hadiths of both Sahih and classification and talking about it
all scientists of hadith are agreed that the Bukhari is the precedent and nothing is contradictory in that and what have been copied from Iraqi about the opposed Ali Ibn salah as, the study has summarized that the Imam Moslem when he met with Imam bukhari are still in classification and is not proved until now that the Sahih before his death with few years as the study showed that the written history of journey of bukhari and Moslem and their meeting with the Elders were a part to show the core problems about classification of Sahih and which one is the precedent of them

Keywords

Main Subjects

الحديث وعلومه

References

References
1. al'arbaewun albuldaniatu, eali bin alhasan abn easakri, tahqiqa: mustafaa eashur, maktabat alqurani, alqahirati.
2. 'iirshad alsaari lisharh sahih albukharii, 'ahmad alqistalani, almatbaeat al'amiriati, masr, ta7, 1323h.
3. al'iirshad fi maerifat eulama' alhadithi, 'abu yaelaa alkhalili, khalil bin eabd allah alqazwini, tahqiqu: muhamad 'iidris, maktabat alrushdi, alrayad, ta1, 1409hi.
4. 'asami man rawaa eanhum muhamad bin 'iismaeil albukhariu min mashayikhih fi jamieih alsahihi, 'ahmad eabd allah bin eadi aljirjani, tahqiqu: eamir hasan sabri, albashayir al'iislamiatu, bayrut, ta1, 1414h.
5. 'iifadat alnasih fi altaerif bisanad aljamie alsahihi, aibn rashid alsabti alfihraya, tahqiqu: muhamad alkhawjat.
6. al'iifsah ean maeani alsahahi, yahyaa bin hubirata, tahqiqu: fuaad eabd almuneim, dar alwatani, 1417h.
7. 'iikmal tahdhib alkamal fi 'asma' alrijali, mughaltay bin qalija, tahqiqa: eadil bin muhamad, wa'usamat bin 'iibrahima, alfaruq alhadithati, ta1, 1422hi, 2001m.
8. al'iikmal fi rafe alairtiab ean almutalaf walmukhtalaf fi al'asma' walkunaa walannasab, eali bin makula,dar alkutub aleilmiata, bayrut, lubnan, ta1, 1411-1990.
9. al'iimam muslim bin alhajaaj alqushayrii alnaysaburiu hayatuh wasahihuhu, mahmud fakhuri, 'aelamuna (2).
10. al'amam muslim bin alhajaaj sahib almusnad alsahih wamuhdith al'iislam alkabira, mashhur hasanu, dar alqalami, dimashqa, ta1, 1414h1994m.
11. al'iimam muslim wamanhajuh fi sahihihi, muhamad altawalibati, dar eamar, ta2, 1421h-2000m,
12. al'ansab, eabd alkarim alsimeani, tahqiqu: majlis dayirat almaearif aleuthmaniati, alhindi, ta1, 1382h.
13. al'awayil alsanbiliatu, lisanbil almakii, maktabat almatbueat al'iislamiati, bayrut, ta1, 1427h.
14. albidayat walnihayatu, 'iismaeil bin eumar bn kathir (t 774 ha), tahqiqu: alturki, dar hijr, ta1, 1418h.
15. badayie alfawayidi, abn alqiam aljawziatu, muhamad bin 'abi bakr, tahqiqu: ealii aleumran, ealim alfawayidi, ta1,1425hi.
16. barnamaj altajibi, alqasim bin yusif altajibi, tahqiqu: eabd alhafiz mansur, aldaar alearabiat, liba, 1981m.
17. tarikh al'iislami,muhamad bin qimaz aldhahbi, tahqiqu: bashaar eawad maerufun, dar algharba, ta1, 2003m.
18. altaarikh al'awsata. albukharii, muhamad, tahqiqu: zayidi, alqahirati, alwaei, 1397hi.
19. tarikh alturath alearabii lifuad sazkin, naqlah 'iilaa alearabiati: mahmud hijazi, warajaeah: earafat mustafaa, wasaeid eabd alrahim, 'iidarat althaqafat walnashr bijamieat al'iimam muhamad bin sueud al'iislamiati, 1411h1991m.
20. altaarikh alkabira, muhamad bin 'iismaeil albukhari, tahqiqu: alddabas, dar altamayuzu, alrayad, ta1, 1440.
21. tarikh baghdad, 'ahmad bin ealiin alkhatayb, tahqiqu: bashaar eawadi, algharb al'iislamii, bayrut, ta1, 1422h.
22. tarikh dimashqa, eali bin easakri, tahqiqu: aleumrawi, bayrut: alfikri, 1415hi.
23. tabsir almuntabah bitahrir almushtabahi, 'ahmad bin eali aibn hajar, tahqiqi: alnijari, almaktabat aleilmiati, bayrut, lubnan.
24. altuhfat allatifat fi tarikh almadinat alsharifati, muhamad alsakhawii, alkutub aleilmiatu, bayrut, ta1, 1414h.
25. tadrib alraawy fi sharh taqrib alnawawi, eabd alrahman alsuyuti, tahqiqa: nazar alfaryabi, dar tib.
26. tadhkirat alhafazi, muhamad bin 'ahmad aldhahbi, dar alkutub aleilmiati, bayrut, ta1, 1419hi, 1998m.
27. tarjamat al'iimam albukhari, eali bin eabd almuhsin bin alddwalibi, tahqiqu: eabd alrahim muhamad yusfan, makhtuta, manshur ealaa mawsueat sahih al'iimam albukhari, dar alkamali.
28. altaedil waltajrih liman kharaj lah albukhariu fi aljamie alsahihi, sulayman bin khalaf albaji, tahqiqu: 'abu lababat husayn, dar alliwa'i, alrayad, ta1, 1406h.
29. taghliq altaeliq ealaa sahih albukhari, aleasqalani, 'ahmad bin eali bin hajar aleasqalani, tahqiqu: saeid eabd alrahman alqazqi, ta1, almaktab al'iislamia, dar eamar, eaman, 1405hi.
30. taqrib altahdhibi, 'ahmad bin ealii aleasqalani, tahqiqu: muhamad eawaamatu, dar alrashid, surya, ta1, 1406h.
31. taqyid almahmal lilghasani, tahqiqu: ealii aleumran, wamuhamad shamsi, dar ealam alfawayidi, alsueudiati, ta1, 1421h.
32. altaqyid limaerifat ruat alsunan walmasanidi, muhamad abn nuqtata, tahqiqi: alhawti, alkutub aleilmiatu, ta1, 1408hi.
33. altaqyid wal'iidah sharh muqadimat aibn alsalahi, eabd alrahim bin alhusayn aleiraqii, tahqiqu: eabd alrahman euthman, almaktabat alsalafiati, almadinat almunawarati, ta1, 1389hi, 1969m.
34. takmilat al'iikmali, muhamad abn nuqtata, eabd alqayumi, jamieat 'um alquraa, alsueudiati, ta1, 1408hi.
35. tahadhib al'asma' wallughati. alnawawii, yahyaa, tahqiqu: shirakat aleulama'i, bayrut: alkutub aleilmiatu.
36. tahadhib altahdhibi. abn hajara, 'ahmada, ta1, alnahdi: matbaeat almaearifi, 1326h
37. tahadhib alkamal fi 'asma alrajali, yusif almazi, tahqiqu: bashaar maeruf, alrisalati, bayrut ta1, 1441h.
38. tawdih almushtabah fi dabt 'asma' alrruat wa'ansabihim wa'alqabihim wakunahum, muhamad bin eabd allah bin nasir aldiyn aldimashqi, tahqiqu: muhamad aleirqasusi, muasasat alrisalati, bayrut, ta1, 1993m.
39. altawdih lisharh aljamie alsahihi, abn almalqan, tahqiqu: dar alfalah lilbahth aleilmii watahqiq altarathu, dar alnawadira, dimashqa, ta1, 1429 hi.
40. althiqat miman lam yaqae fi alkutub alsitatu, qasim bin qutlubagha, tahqiqu: shadi al nueman, markaz alnueman, sanea', alyaman, ta1, 1432-2011.
41. althiqati, muhamad bin hbban albasti, wizarat almaearif lilhukumat alealiat alhindiat taht muraqabati: muhamad khan, dayirat almaearif aleuthmaniati, haydar abad aldakn, alhinda, ta1, 1393-1973.
42. aljamie li'akhlaq alrrawy wadab alsaamiei, alkhatiba, 'ahmad bin eulay, tahqiqa: altahaani, maktabat almaearif,alriyad
43. aljurh waltaedili, eabd alrahman bin 'abi hatim alraazi, tabeat majlis dayirat almaearif aleuthmaniati, haydar abad aldakn, alhindu, dar 'iihya' alturath alearabi, bayrut, ta1, 1271-1952
44. jawahir al'usul fi eilm hadith alrasul r, muhamad alfarisi, fasih alhurwii, tahqiqu: 'athar almubarikifuri, ta1, 1422h.
45. hashiat radi almuhtari, ealaa alduri almukhtar, muhamad 'amin abn eabdin, albabii alhalbi, ta2, 1386hi.
46. alkhulasat fi maerifat alhadithi, alhusayn altaybi, tahqiqa: alshawami, almaktabat al'iislamiati, alta1, 1430hi.
47. ruayat aljamie alsahih wanusakhuhu, dirasat nazariat tatbiqiatun, fathi eabd alhalimi, (1/190).
48. sualat albaradheii li'abi zareat alraazi, tahqiqu: al'azhari, alfaruq alhadithatu, alqahiratu, ta1, 1430h.
49. suaalat hamzat alsahmi, hamzat bin yusif alsahmi, tahqiqu: muafaq bin eabd allah, maktabat almaearifi, alrayad, ta1, 1404h.
50. sir 'aelam alnubala'i, muhamad bin 'ahmad aldhahabii (t 748 hu), tahqiqu: majmueat min almuhaqiqin bi'iishraf alshaykh shueayb al'arnawuwta, muasasat alrisalati, ta3, 1405h.
51. alshadha alfayaah min eulum abn alsalahi, al'abnasi, 'iibrahim bin musaa, tahqiqu: salah hilla, maktabat alrishdi, ta1, 1418hi.
52. sharah 'usul aietiqad 'ahl alsunat waljamaeati, hibat allah bin alhasan allaalkayiy, tahqiqu: 'ahmad alghamidi, dar tibat, alsaeudiat, ta8, 1423h.
53. sharh alnawawiu ealaa sahih muslimin, yahyaa bin sharaf, 'iihya' altarathi, bayrut, ta2, 1392h.
54. shurut al'ayimati, muhamad bin 'iishaq abn mandah, tahqiqu: alfiryawayiy, dar almuslimi, alrayad, ta1, 1414hi.
55. shmayil albukharii li'abi jaefar alnahawii alwaraqi, jame wataeliqu: mazin albayruti, ta1, 1440hi.
56. alsihah taj allughat wasihah alearabiat, aljawharii, aismaeil bin hamad, tahqiqu: 'ahmad eabd alghafur eataar ta4, dar aleilm lilmalayini, bayrut, ta4, 1407h 1987m.
57. sahih albukharii. albukharii, muhamad, tahqiqu: jamaeat min aleulama'i, ta1, bayrut: tawq alnajati, 1422hi.
58. sianat sahih muslam min al'iikhlal walghalat wahimayatih min al'iisqat walsaqatu, euthman bin eabd alrahman aibn alsalahi, tahqiqu: muafaq eabdallah eabdalqadir, algharb al'iislamiu, bayrut, ta2, 1408h.
59. tabaqat alhanabilati, muhamad bin 'abi yaelaa, tahqiqu: muhamad alfaqi, matbaeat alsunat almuhamadiati, alqahiratu, 1371hi.
60. tabaqat eulama' alhadithi, muhamad bin 'ahmad bin eabd alhadi alhanbali, tahqiqu: 'akram albushi, 'iibrahim alziybqa, muasasat alrisalati, bayrut, lubnan, ta2, 1417-1996.
61. altyuryati, 'ahmad bin muhamad abn tahir alsalafi, muntakhab min 'usuli: 'abi alhusayn altayuri, tahqiqu: sman yahyaa, waeabaas sakhra, 'adwa' alsalaf, alrayad, ta1, 1425h.
62. eadad alsafahati: shifa' alsaqami, lilsabki, tahqiqu: husayn muhamad eali shukri, dar alkutub aleilmiati, bayrut, ta1, 2008m.
63. earaf aleanbar fi wasf alminbari, muhamad bin eabd allah aibn nasir aldiyn aldimashqi, tahqiqa: almutayri, dar aibn hazma, bayrut, ta1, 1422hi.
64. fath albari sharh sahih albukhari, 'ahmad bin ealiin bin hajar alesqlannay, 'iishrafi: muhibi aldiyn alkhatib, dar almaerifati, bayrut, 1379.
65. fath almughith bisharh 'alfiat alhadithi, muhamad bin eabd alrahman alsakhawi, tahqiqu: ealiin husayn ealay, maktabat alsanati, masr, ta1, 1424hi, 2003m.
66. alfarayid almuntazimat walfawayid almahkamatu, muhamad bin 'ahmad alghayti, tahqiqu: muhamad tahir shaeban, makhtuta, manshur ealaa mawsueat sahih albukhari, dar alkamali.
67. fahrasat abn khayrin, abn khayr al'iishbili, tahqiqu: bashaar eawadi, dar algharb al'iislami, tunis, ta1, 2009m.
68. alfawayid aldirariu fi tarjamat al'iimam albukhari, 'iismaeil bin muhamad aleajluni, muqabalatu: muhamad tawfiq taklat, makhtuta, manshur ealaa mawsueat sahih albukhari, dar alkamali.
69. qut almughtadhi ealaa jamie altirmidhi, eabd alrahman alsuyuti, 'iiedadu: nasir algharibi, risalat dukturati, jamieat 'umm alquraa, makat almukaramati, kuliyat aldaewat wa'usul aldiyn, qism alkitaab walsanati, 1424hi.
70. alkafi fi eulum alhadithi, eali altabrizi, tahqiqu: mashhur bin hasan, aldaar al'athariatu, eaman, ta1, 1429hi.
71. alkamil fi dueafa' alrijal, eabd allah bin eadi aljirjani, tahqiqu: eadil eabd almawjud, waeali mueawad, bimusharakati: eabd alfataah 'abu sanat, alkutub aleilmiata, bayrut, lubnan, ta1, 1418hi- 1997m.
72. ktab al'arbaein fi aljihad walmujahidin lilmuqrii, tahqiqu: badr albadar, abn aljuzi, ta2, 1415hi.
73. kashf alzunun lihaji khalifata, dar 'iihya' alturath alearabi, bayrut.
74. lsan almizani, 'ahmad bin eali bin hajar aleasqalani, tahqiqu: dayirat almaearif alnizamiati, alhinda, muasasat al'aelami, bayrut, lubnan, ta2, 1390h.
75. almutafaq walmuftaraqu, 'ahmad bin alkhatib albaghdadii, tahqiqu: muhamad alhamidi, alqadiri, dimashqa, ta1, 1417h.
76. mahasin aliastilahi, eumar bin raslan albalqiniu, tahqiqu: bint alshaatii, kuliyat alsharieat bifasi, jamieat alqaruawin, dar almaearifi.
77. almukhtasar alnasih lilmuhlab fi tahdhib alkitaab aljamie alsahihi, almuhalab bin 'ahmad, tahqiqu: 'ahmad alsalumu, dar altawhida, dar 'ahl alsanati, alrayad, ta1, 1430h.
78. almadkhal 'iilaa alsanan, 'ahmad bin alhusayn albayhaqi, tahqiqu: muhamad eawaamatu, dar alyusri, alqahirat ta1, 1437h.
79. almadkhal 'iilaa sahih albukhari, tahqiqu: rabie almadkhali, muasasat alrisalati, bayrut, ta1, 1404h.
80. almadkhal 'iilaa kitab al'iiklil, muhamad alhakim alnaysaburi, tahqiqu: fuad eabd almuneim, dar aldaewati, al'iiskandiriati.
81. mirat alzaman fi tawarikh al'aeyan, yusif bin qiz'uwghly sabt aibn aljuzi, tahqiqu: majmueat min almuhaqiqina, dar alrisalat alealamiati, dimashqa, ta1, 1434h.
82. marqat almafatih sharh mishkat almasabihi, eali alharawi alqariy, dar alfikri, bayrut, ta1, 1422h.
83. almasalik walmamaliki, 'iibrahim bin muhamad aliastukhari, dar sadir, birut, 2004m.
84. almasalik walmamaliki, eubayd allah bin eabd allah abn khardadhibata, dar sadir 'afsat lidn, birut, 1889m.
85. mashikhat 'abi almawahib alhanbali, muhamad bin eabd albaqi albaelii aldimashqi, tahqiqu: muhamad mutie alhafizi, dar alfikri, bayrut, ta1, 1410h 1990m.
86. mashikhat alqazwini, eumar alqazwini, tahqiqu: eamir hasan sabri, dar albashayir al'iislamiati, ta1, 1426hi.
87. maealim alsanan, hamad bin muhamad alkhatabi, almatbaeat aleilmiati, halba, ta1, 1351hi.
88. almuejam almuasis lilmuejam almufaharisi, 'ahmad bin ealiin abn hajar aleasqalani, tahqiqu: almaraeshali, dar almaerifati, bayrut, ta1, 1413h.
89. maerifat 'anwae eulum alhadithi, alshahrazuri, euthman bin eabd alrahman, tahqiqu: eabd allatif alhaythama, mahir yasin alfahala, ta1, dar alkutub aleilmiati, 1423hi 2002m.
90. almuealim bishuyukh albukharii wamuslmi, muhamad abn khalfun, tahqiqu: eadil bin saedu, alkutub aleilmiatu, bayrut, ta1.
91. almafham lama 'ushakil min talkhis kitab muslmin, 'ahmad bin eumar alqurtubi: tahqiqa: muhyi aldiyn mistu, wakhrun, dar aibn kathir, dimashqa, ta1, 1417h
92. maqayis allughati, abn fars, 'ahmad bin faris, tahqiqu: eabd alsalam harun, dar alfikri, 1399hi.
93. almuqanie fi eulum alhadithi, eumar abn almalqan, tahqiqu: aljadiea, dar fawaz lilnashri, alsueudiati, ta1, 1413hi.
94. almuntakhab min kitab alsiyaq litarikh nisabur, lieabd alghafir alfarsi, aintakhabaha: 'abu'iishaq alsiyrfini, tahqiqu: khalid haydar, dar alfikri, bayrut, 1414h.
95. almuntazim fi tarikh al'umam walmuluki, eabd alrahman bin eali aljuzi, tahqiqu: muhamad eabd alqadir eataa, mustafaa eabd alqadir eataa, dar alkutub aleilmiati, bayrut, ta1, 1412h.
96. mawqif al'iimamayn albukharii wamuslam min aishtirat alluqya walsamae fi alsinad almuenaen bayn almutaeasirina, khalid aldiris, maktabat alrushdi, alriyad, sharikat alriyad lilnashr waltawziei.
97. alnujum alzaahirat fi muluk misr walqahirati, yusif bin tughri bardi, wazarat althaqafati, dar alkatab, masr.
98. nuzhat almushtaq fi akhtiraq alafaqi, muhamad bin muhamad aladrisi, ealim alkutab, bayrut, ta1, 1409hi.
99. alinakt alwafiat bima fi sharh al'alfiati, albiqaeiu, 'iibrahim bin eumra, tahqiqu: mahir yasin alfahala, ta1, maktabat alrashid nashruna, 1428h2007m.
100. nakat ealaa jawab 'abi maseud aldimashqi, 'ahmad al'aqtashu, alshabakat aleankabutiat, https://2u.pw/43Tzcl.
101. alnakt ealaa kitab aibn alsalahi, 'ahmad bin eali bin hajar aleasqalani, tahqiqu: rabie almadkhali, eimadat albahth aleilmii bialjamieat al'iislamiati, almadinat almunawarati, alsueudiati, ta1,1404-1984.
102. alnakt ealaa muqadimat aibn alsalahi, alzarkashi, muhamad bin eabd allah, tahqiqu: zayn aleabidin bila furiji, 'adwa' alsalaf, alrayad, ta1, 1419h.
103. wfiaat al'aeyan wa'anba' 'abna' alzaman, 'ahmad bin muhamad aibn khalkan, tahqiqu: 'iihsan eabaas, dar sadir, birut, ta7, 1994m.