Balancing in the interpretational direction of al-Baqir and al-Sadiq Between the interpretations of the Sunnis and the interpretations of the Shiites

Author

Department of the Qur’an and its Sciences, College of Sharia, Qassim University, Saudi Arabia

Abstract

This research deals with a balance between the interpretive approach of Imam al-Baqir and al-Sadiq in the interpretations of the Sunnis and the interpretations of the Shiites.
The research came in an introduction, a preface, four topics, and a conclusion. As for the introduction: it included the research methodology, its problem, an indication of its importance, its objectives, the research methodology, and its plan. The introduction came in introducing Muhammad al-Baqir and his son Jaafar al-Sadiq, and the first topic in the balance in the interpretation related to faith, and the second topic in the balance in the interpretation related to jurisprudence and its origins, and the balance in the interpretation related to the language, and the fourth topic: the balance in the sources of interpretation. As for the conclusion: it included the most important results, including: that Muhammad al-Baqir and his son Jaafar al-Sadiq have a great place in the hearts of Muslims, for God combined for them the two honors of knowledge and lineage, for they are Hashemite, and among the imams of Ahl al-Bayt, and that their approach to interpretation among the Sunnis and the community is similar to the approaches of The imams who interpreted the Companions and the followers before them, such as the interpretation of the Qur’an by the Qur’an, the interpretation of the Qur’an by the Sunnah, the interpretation of the Qur’an by the sayings of the Companions and the Followers, and the interpretation of the Qur’an by opinion and ijtihad, and that the Shiites have gone to extremes in their right as is their case in Aal al-Bayt, so they attributed to them exegetical sayings that contradict the explicit Sunnah and what was reported from The other companions sometimes distorted their sayings in order to make them agree with their false beliefs, and that the disagreement between the interpretations of the Sunnis and the interpretations of the Shiites is a disagreement in the origin and head of Islam, which is the Holy Qur’an.The study recommends conducting a study of the sayings of all the Twelver Shiite imams, a comparative study between the interpretations of the Sunnis and the Shiites, and conducting a special study of the chains of interpretation of the Shiites, and verifying them, and conducting a study that collects the sayings in which Al-Baqir and Al-Sadiq agree in the books of the Sunnah.

Keywords

Main Subjects


  1. References :

    1. al'asami walkunaa ll'iimam 'ahmd bin hanbal riwayat abnh salh, li'ahmad bin muhamad bin hanbal alshiybani,(ta: 241hi), almuhaqiq: eabd allah bin yusif aljadiei, alnaashir: maktabat dar al'aqsaa - alkuayt, altabeatu: al'uwlaa, 1406 - 1985m.
    2. al'iitqan fi eulum alqurani, lieabd alrahman jalal aldiyn alsuyutii (t: 911hi), almuhaqaqa: muhamad 'abu alfadl 'iibrahim, alnaashir: alhayyat almisriat aleamat lilkitabi, 1394hi/ 1974m.
    3. ara' alshiyeat al'iithni eishriat fi alsahabat min khilal tafsirihim lilquran alkarimi: eard wadirasatu, almualafi: yusif bin khalaf bin salim almuzeala, risalat majistir, jamieat alqasimi, 1437h.
    4. aliastighna' fi maerifat almashhurin min hamalat aleilm bialkunaa li'abi eumar yusif bin eabd allh bin eabd albiri alnamirii alqurtibii (t:463 ha), dirasat watahqiq watakhriju: eabd allah marhul alsuwalimat, alnaashir: dar aibn taymiat lilnashr waltawzie wal'iielami, alriyad - almamlakat alearabiat alsaeudiat, altabeati: al'uwlaa, 1405h - 1985m.
    5. al'iisabat fi tamyiz alsahabati, li'ahmad bin ealiin bin muhamad bin 'ahmad bin hajar aleasqalanii (t: 852hi), tahqiqu: eadil 'ahmad eabd almawjud waealaa muhamad mueawad, alnaashir: dar alkutub aleilmiat - bayrut, altabeatu: al'uwlaa - 1415 hu.
    6. 'usul madhhab alshiyeat al'iimamiat al'iithni eishriat - eard wanaqd -, almualafi: nasir bin eabd allah bin eali alqafari, dar alnashri: bidun, altabeati: al'uwlaa, 1414 hu
    7. aietiqadat firaq almuslimin walmushrikina, limuhamad bin eumar almulaqab bifakhr aldiyn alraazii (t: 606h), almuhaqiq: eali sami alnashar, alnaashir: dar alkutub aleilmiat - bayrut.
    8. al'iikmal fi rafe alairtiab ean almutalaf walmukhtalaf fi al'asma' walkunaa wal'ansab li'abi nasr eali bin hibat allah bin jaefar bin makula (t: 475hi), alnaashir: dar alkutub aleilmiat -birut-lubnan, altabeati: altabeat al'uwlaa 1411h-1990m
    9. tarikh dimashqa, li'abi alqasim ealiin bin alhasan bin hibat allah almaeruf biabn easakir (t: 571hi), almuhaqiqi: eamru bin gharamat aleumrui, alnaashir: dar alfikr liltibaeat walnashr waltawziei, eam alnashri: 1415 hi - 1995m.
    10. altafsir allughawiu lilquran alkarimi, limusaeid bin sulayman bin nasir altayaar, alnaashir: dar abn aljuzi, altabeati: al'uwlaa, 1432hi.
    11. altafsir almuduei lilquran alkarim li'ahmad alsayid alkumi wamuhamad 'ahmad alqasima, altabeat al'uwlaa sanat 1402h.
    12. tahadhib altahdhib li'abi alfadl 'ahmad bin ealii bin muhamad bin 'ahmad bin hajar aleasqalanii (t: 852h), alnaashir: matbaeat dayirat almaearif alnizamiati, alhinda, altabeat al'uwlaa, 1326hi.
    13. tahadhib alkamal fi 'asma' alrijal, liusif bin eabd alrahman bin yusif, 'abu alhajaji, jamal aldiyn almaziy (t: 742h), almuhaqiq: du. bashaar eawad maeruf, alnaashir: muasasat alrisalat - bayrut, altabeatu: al'uwlaa, 1400 - 1980m.
    14. althiqati, limuhamad bin hibaan bin 'ahmad bin hibaan 'abu hatim albusty (t: 354h), alnaashir: dayirat almaearif aleuthmaniat bihaydar abad aldukn alhindu.
    15. aljamie almusnad alsahih almukhtasar min 'umur rasul allah e wasunanuh wa'ayaamuh (shih albukharii), limuhamad bin 'iismaeil 'abu eabdallah albukhari almuhaqaqa: muhamad zuhayr bin nasir alnaasir, alnaashir: dar tawq alnajaat altabeatu: al'uwlaa, 1422hi.
    16. aljamie li'ahkam alquran (tafsir alqurtubii), li'abi eabd allah muhamad bin 'ahmad bin 'abi bakr alqurtibii (t: 671hi), tahqiqu: 'ahmad albarduni wa'iibrahim 'atfish, alnaashir: dar alkutub almisriat - alqahirati, altabeatu: althaaniatu, 1384h - 1964m.
    17. jawahir aleaqdayn fi fadl alshirfini, lieali bin eabd allah alhasni alsamhudii, almuhaqaqi: musaa binay alealili, alnaashir: wizarat al'awqaf - aleiraqu, sanat alnashr: 1405 - 1984m.
    18. ruh almaeani fi tafsir alquran aleazim walsabe almathani, limahmud bin eabd allah alhusaynii al'alusii (t: 1270hi), almuhaqiq: eali eabd albari eatiat, alnaashir: dar alkutub aleilmiat - bayrut, altabeatu: al'uwlaa, 1415hi.
    19. sir 'aelam alnubala'i, lishams aldiyn muhamad bin 'ahmad bin euthman bin qaymaz aldhahabii (t: 748hi), almuhaqiq : majmueat min almuhaqiqin bi'iishraf alshaykh shueayb al'arnawuwta, alnaashir: muasasat alrisalati, altabeat : althaalithat , 1405 hi / 1985m.
    20. shdharat aldhahab fi 'akhbar min dhahabi, lieabd alhayi bin 'ahmad bin muhamad aibn aleimad alhanbali, (t: 1089hi), haqaqahu: mahmud al'arnawuwta, alnaashir: dar aibn kathir, dimashq bayrut, altabeata: al'uwlaa, 1406 hi - 1986m.
    21. shaeb al'iiman, li'ahmad bin alhusayn bin ealiin bin musaa albayhaqi (t: 458h), haqaqahu: alduktur eabd aleali eabd alhamid hamid, alnaashir: maktabat alrushd lilnashr waltawzie bialriyad bialtaeawun mae aldaar alsalafiat bibumbay bialhindi, altabeatu: al'uwlaa, 1423 hi - 2003m.
    22. alshiyeat aliathnaa eashriat wamanhajuhum fi tafsir alquran alkarimi, almualafi: muhamad muhamad 'iibrahim aleasaali, sanat alnashri: 1424hi.

     

     

    1. altabaqat alkubraa, limuhamad bin saed bin maniye alhashimii almaeruf biaibn saed (t: 230hi), tahqiqu: muhamad eabd alqadir eata, alnaashir: dar alkutub aleilmiat - bayrut, altabeatu: al'uwlaa, 1410 ha 1990m.
    2. tabaqat almufasirin lildaawudi, limuhamad bin ealii bin 'ahmadu, aldaawudii almalikii (t: 945ha), alnaashir: dar alkutub aleilmiat - bayrut.
    3. tabaqat eulama' alhaditha, limuhamad bin 'ahmad bin eabd alhadi aldimashqii alsaalihii (t: 744 hu), tahqiqu: 'akram albushi, 'iibrahim alziybiq, alnaashir: muasasat alrisalat liltibaeat walnashr waltawzie, bayrut - lubnan, altabeata: althaaniati, 1417hi- 1996m.
    4. eaqayid alshiyeat al'iimamiat aliathnay eashriat alraafidati, li'ashraf aljizawi, dar alyaqin lilnashr waltawziei, sanat alnashri: 1430h.
    5. fath almughith bisharh 'alfiat alhadith lileiraqi, lishams aldiyn muhamad bin eabd alrahman alsakhawi (t: 902h), almuhaqiq: eali husayn eulay, alnaashir: maktabat alsanat - masr, altabeati: al'uwlaa, 1424h / 2003m.
    6. alkamil fi altaarikhi, lieali bin 'abi alkaram muhamad bin muhamad aljazari, eizi aldiyn abn al'uthayr (t: 630hi), tahqiqu: eumar eabd alsalam tudamuri, alnaashir: dar alkitaab alearabi, bayrut - lubnan, altabeata: al'uwlaa, 1417h / 1997m.
    7. kashf alniqab ean al'asma' wal'alqabi, lieabd alrahman bin eali bin muhamad aljuzi, almuhaqaqa: eabd aleaziz bin raji alsaaeidi, alnaashir: maktabat dar alsalami, sanat alnashri: 1993m.
    8. alkashf walbayan ean tafsir alqurani, li'abi 'iishaq 'ahmad bin 'iibrahim althaelabii (t: 427hi), tahqiqu: eadad min albahithin alnaashir: dar altafsiri, jidat - almamlakat alearabiat alsaeudiat, altabeati: al'uwlaa, 1436 hi - 2015m.
    9. alkunaa wal'asma'i, limuslim bin alhajaaj alqushayrii alnaysaburii (t: 261hi), almuhaqiq: eabd alrahim muhamad 'ahmad alqashqari, alnaashir: eimadat albahth aleilmii bialjamieat al'iislamiati, almadinat almunawarati, altabeatu: al'uwlaa, 1404h/1984m.
    10. majmae aladab fi muejam al'alqabi, lieabd alrazaaq bin 'ahmad almaeruf biaibn alfutii alshaybanii (t: 723 ha), almuhaqiqa: muhamad alkazim, alnaashir: muasasat altibaeat walnashri- wizarat althaqafat wal'iirshad al'iislami, 'iiran, altabeatu: al'uwlaa, 1416hi.
    11. majmue alfatawaa, li'ahmad bin eabd alhalim bin taymiat alharaanii (t: 728hi), almuhaqiq: eabdalrahman bin muhamad bin qasimi, alnaashir: majmae almalik fahd litibaeat almushaf alsharifi, almadinat alnabawiati, eam alnashri: 1416h/1995m.
    12. mirat aljanan waeibrat alyaqzan fi maerifat ma yuetabar min hawadith alzaman, lieafif aldiyn eabd allah bin 'asead bin eali alyafieii (t: 768hi), alnaashir: dar alkutub aleilmiati, bayrut lubnan, altabeata: al'uwlaa, 1417 hi - 1997m.
    13. maruiaat al'iimam jaefar alsaadiq fi alsunat alnabawiat wa'ahwal alruwat eanh wanamadhij mimaa nusib 'iilayhi, almualifu: latifat 'iibrahim alqasim alhadi, jamieatan 'ami alquraa 1422h.
    14. almusnad alsahih almukhtasar binaql aleadl ean aleadl 'iilaa rasul allah e (shih muslimi), limuslim bin alhajaaj alnaysaburii (t: 261hi), almuhaqaqi: muhamad fuad eabd albaqi, alnaashir: dar 'iihya' alturath alearabii - bayrut.
    15. masadir altalaqiy wa'usul aliastidlal aleaqdiat eind al'iimamiat al'iithnaa eishriat, li'iiman salih aleulwani, dar altadmuriati, sanat alnashri: 2008m.
    16. maejam mustalahat eulum alqurani, limuhamad bin eabd alrahman alshaayie , dar altadmuriati, alriyad , sanat alnashri: 1433 hi / 2012m.
    17. mafatih alghib, limuhamad bin eumar bin alhasan alraazi almulaqab bifakhr aldiyn alraazi (t: 606h), alnaashir: dar 'iihya' alturath alearabii - bayrut, altabeata: althaalithat - 1420hi.
    18. muqadimat fi 'usul altafsiri, li'ahmad bin eabd alhalim abn taymiat aldimashqii (t: 728hi), alnaashir: dar maktabat alhayati, bayrut, lubnan, altabeati: 1490hi/ 1980m.
    19. almuntazim fi tarikh al'umam walmuluki, li'abi alfaraj eabd alrahman bin ealii bin muhamad aljawzii (t: 597h), almuhaqaqi: muhamad eabd alqadir eataa, wakhar, alnaashir: dar alkutub aleilmiati, bayrut, altabeatu: al'uwlaa, 1412 hi - 1992m.
    20. minhaj alsunat alnabawiat fi naqd kalam alshiyeat alqadariati, li'ahmad bin eabd alhalim aibn taymiat alharaanii alhanbalii aldimashqii (t: 728h), almuhaqaqa: muhamad rashad salima, alnaashir: jamieat al'iimam muhamad bin sueud al'iislamiati, altabeatu: al'uwlaa, 1406 hi - 1986m.
    21. almuafaqati, li'iibrahim bin musaa bin muhamad algharnatii alshahir bialshaatibii (t: 790hi), almuhaqiqi: 'abu eubaydat mashhur bin hasan al salman, alnaashir: dar aibn eafan, altabeat al'uwlaa 1417hi/ 1997m.
    22. almawsueat alquraniatu, almualafu: 'iibrahim bin 'iismaeil al'abyarii (ta: 1414ha), alnaashir: muasasat sijil alearabi, altabeati: 1405hi.
    23. alnujum alzaahirat fi muluk misr walqahirati, liusif bin tughri bardi (t: 874hi), alnaashir: wazarat althaqafat wal'iirshad alqawmii, dar alkatab, masr.

     

     

    1. nuzhat al'albab fi al'alqabi, li'ahmad bin ealii bin muhamad abn hajar aleasqalanii (t: 852h), almuhaqiq: eabd aleaziz muhamad alsudiri, alnaashir: maktabat alrushd - alrayad, altabeatu: al'uwlaa, 1409h-1989m.
    2. wfiaat al'aeyan wa'anba' 'abna' alzaman, lishams aldiyn 'ahmad bin muhamad bin 'iibrahim aibn khalkan (t: 681hi), almuhaqiqu: 'iihsan eabaas, alnaashir: dar sadir - bayrut.
    3. almuafaqati, li'iibrahim bin musaa bin muhamad algharnatii alshahir bialshaatibii (t: 790hi), almuhaqiqi: 'abu eubaydat mashhur bin hasan al salman, alnaashir: dar aibn eafan, altabeat al'uwlaa 1417hi/ 1997m.
    4. almawsueat alquraniatu, almualafu: 'iibrahim bin 'iismaeil al'abyarii (ta: 1414ha), alnaashir: muasasat sijil alearabi, altabeati: 1405hi.
    5. alnujum alzaahirat fi muluk misr walqahirati, liusif bin tughri bardi (t: 874hi), alnaashir: wazarat althaqafat wal'iirshad alqawmii, dar alkatab, masr.
    6. nuzhat al'albab fi al'alqabi, li'ahmad bin ealii bin muhamad abn hajar aleasqalanii (t: 852h), almuhaqiq: eabd aleaziz muhamad alsudiri, alnaashir: maktabat alrushd - alrayad, altabeatu: al'uwlaa, 1409h-1989m.
    7. wfiaat al'aeyan wa'anba' 'abna' alzaman, lishams aldiyn 'ahmad bin muhamad bin 'iibrahim aibn khalkan (t: 681hi), almuhaqiqu: 'iihsan eabaas, alnaashir: dar sadir - bayrut.
    8. altafsir alsaafi, lilfayd alkashani, taeliq alealaamat alshaykh husayn al'aelami, maktabat alsadr - tahran, sanat alnashr: 1416h.
    9. tafsir alqami, lieali bin 'iibrahim alqumi, tashih wataeliq wataqdimu: alsayid tayib almusawi aljazayirii, muasasat dar alkitab liltibaeat walnashr - qim - 'iiran, sanat alnashri: 1404h.
    10. tafsir almizani, lilsayid altabatibayiy, muasasat alnashr al'iislamii altaabieat lijamaeat almudarisin biqim.
    11. tafsir majmae albayani, lilfadl bin alhasan altabarsi, dar aleulum liltahqiq waltibaeat walnashri, sanat alnashri:1426h.
    12. drus fi 'usul fiqh al'iimamiati, lieabd alhadi alfadli, markaz alghadir lildirasat walnashr waltawziei- bayrut, sanat alnashr: 1428h.
    13. fasal alkhitaab fi eadam tahrif kitab rabi al'arbabi, lisulayman 'akh muhamad bin eabd alwahaabi, muasasat qiam - qim- 'iiran, sanat alnashr: 1376h.
    14. alquran fi al'iislami, lilsayid muhamad husayn altabaatibayiy, dar alzahra' liltibaeat walnushri- bayrut, sanat alnashr 1393h.
    15. alkafi, lilshaykh alklini, tashih wataeliqu: eali 'akbar alghafari, dar alkutub al'iislamiat - tahran, sanat alnashri: 1363h.