استيفاء العقوبات الشرعية عند اجتماعها دراسة فقهية مقارنة

المؤلف

أستاذ الفقه وأصوله المساعد قسم الدراسات الإسلامية كلية التربية – جامعة الملك سعود

المستخلص

الملخص :
يقصد هذا البحث إلى بيان معنى العقوبات الشرعية، وبيان نوعها، وكيفية استيفاءها حال اجتماعها على جانٍ واحد.
 وقد خلص البحث إلى أن العقوبة إذا كانت حقاً خالصاً لله تعالى فإنها تستوفى كلها إذا كانت فيما دون القتل لكنها تدخل جميعها في القتل إن كان معها قتل، وإنه إنْ تكرر الموجب بعد إقامة الحد أعيد عليه الحد بتكرر الموجب، وإن تكرر الفعل قبل الحد أكتفى بحد واحد.
وإن كانت العقوبات المجتمعة حقاً خالصاً لآدمي فإنها تستوفى جميعها سواء أكان فيها قتل أم لا.
وإذا اجتمعت عقوبات هي حق خالص لله تعالى وحقوق لآدميين فإن العقوبات كلها تستوفى إن لم يكن فيها قتل، وإن كان فيها قتل فتستوفى حقوق الآدميين وحقوق الله تعالى يحيط بها القتل.
وإذا اجتمعت عقوبات هي حق خالص لله تعالى وحقوق لآدميين فإن العقوبات كلها تستوفى إن لم يكن فيها قتل، وإن كان فيها قتل فتستوفى حقوق الآدميين وحقوق الله يحيط بها القتل، وإن تزاحم الحقان فالمقدم حق الآدمي، والله أعلم.
 

الكلمات الرئيسية

الموضوعات الرئيسية


1.   alquran alkarim.
2.    al'iijmaei: 'abu bakr muhamad bin 'iibrahim bin almundhir alniysaburii almuhaqiqi: fuad eabd almuneim 'ahmadu: dar almuslim lilnashr waltawzie, altabeat al'uwlaa 1425hi.
3.    al'ahkam alsultaniat almualafu: 'abu alhasan ealiin bin muhamad bin muhamad bin habib albasarii albaghdadiu, alshahir bialmawardii (almutawafaa: 450hi) alnaashir: dar alhadith - alqahirati.
4.    'ahkam alquran liaibn alearabii 'ahkam alqurani: alqadi muhamad bin eabd allah 'abu bakr bin alearabii almueafiri alashabili almaliki ,rajie 'usulih wakharaj 'ahadithah wellaq ealayhi: muhamad eabd alqadir eata alnaashir: dar alkutub aleilmiati, bayrut - lubnan altabeati: 3, 1424 hu
5.    alaistidhkari: 'abu eumar yusif bin eabd allh bin muhamad bin eabd albirr bin easim alnamirii alqurtubii tahqiqu: salim muhamad eataa, muhamad eali mueawad: dar alkutub aleilmiat - bayrut tu: 1, 1421
6.    'asnaa almatalib fi sharh rawd altaalib almualifi: zakariaa bin muhamad bin zakariaa al'ansari, zayn aldiyn 'abu yahyaa , alnaashir: dar alkitaab al'iislamii altabeati: bidun tabeatin, wamaeah hashiat alramli alkabira.
7.    al'ashbah walnnazayir ealaa madhhab 'abi hanifat alnnueman almualafa: zayn aldiyn bin 'iibrahim bin muhamad, almaeruf biaibn najim almisrii, wade hawashih wakharaj 'ahadithahu: alshaykh zakariaa eumayrat alnaashir: dar alkutub aleilmiati, bayrut - lubnan altabeata: al'uwlaa, 1419 hi - 1999 m
8.    al'ashbah walnazayiru, almualafi: taj aldiyn alsabiki; eabd alwahaab bin ealii bin eabd alkafi alsabki, 'abu nusar, alnaashir: dar alkutub aleilmiati, sanat alnashri: 1411 - 1991-ta1.
9.    al'ashbah walnazayir; eabd alrahman bin 'abi bakr; jalal aldiyn alsuyuti; dar alkutub aleilmiati; altabeat al'uwlaa; 1411hi - 1990mi.
10.  'iielam almuqiein ean rabi alealamina: muhamad bin 'abi bakr bin 'ayuwb bin saed shams aldiyn aibn qiam aljawziat , tahqiqu: muhamad eabd alsalam 'iibrahim alnaashir: dar alkutub aleilmiat - yayrut altabeatu: 1, 1411h .
11.  al'iiqnae fi masayil al'iijmae almualafi: eali bin muhamad bin eabd almalik alkitamii alhimyri alfasi, 'abu alhasan aibn alqataan , almuhaqaqi: hasan fawzi alsaeidi alnaashir: alfaruq alhadithat liltibaeat walnashr ta: 1, 1424 hu.
12.  al'iiqnae fi fiqh al'iimam 'ahmad bin hanbal almualafa: musaa bin 'ahmad bin musaa bin salim bin eisaa bin salim alhajaawi almaqdisi, thuma alsaalihi, sharaf aldiyn, 'abu alnaja almuhaqiq: eabd allatif muhamad musaa alsabaki alnaashir: dar almaerifat bayrut - lubnan .
13.  al'uma; muhamad bin 'iidris alshaafieii alqurashiu almatlabiu 'abu eabd allah; tahqiqu: rafaeat fawzi eabd almatalabi; alnaashir: dar alwafa'i; sanat alnashr: 1422 - 2001m.
14.  al'iinsaf fi maerifat alraajih min alkhilafi; eala' aldiyn 'abu alhasan almardawi aldimashqiu alsaalihii alhanbali; dar 'iihya' alturath alearabii; altabeati: 2.
15.  albahr alraayiq sharh kanz aldaqayiqi; zayn aldiyn bin 'iibrahim; almaeruf biaibn najim almisri; wafi akhirihi: takmilat albahr alraayiq limuhamad bin husayn bin alhanafii alqadiri; dar alkitaab al'iislamii; altabeati: 2.
16.  bidayat almubtadi fi fiqh al'iimam 'abi hanifat almualafa: eali bin 'abi bakr b alfirghaniu almirghinani, 'abu alhasan burhan aldiyn alnaashir: maktabat wamatbaeat muhamad eali sabh- alqahira
17.  bidayat almujtahid wanihayat almuqtasid almualafu: 'abu alwalid muhamad bin 'ahmad bin muhamad bin 'ahmad bin rushd alqurtubii alshahir biaibn rushd alhafid (almutawafaa: 595hi) alnaashir: dar alhadith - alqahirat altabeatu: bidun tabeat tarikh alnashr: 1425h - 2004 m .
18.  badayie alsanayie fi tartib alsharayiei; eala' aldiyn; 'abu bakr bin maseud alkasanii alhanafii; dar alkutub aleilmiati; altabeati: althaaniati; 1406hi - 1986m.
19.  albinayat sharh alhidayat almualafu: 'abu muhamad mahmud bin 'ahmad alhanafii badr aldiyn aleayni alnaashir: dar alkutub aleilmiat - bayrut, lubnan altabeatu: al'uwlaa, 1420 hu
20.  alibayan fi madhhab al'iimam alshaafieii almualafi: 'abu alhusayn yahyaa bin 'abi alkhayr bin salim aleumranii alyamanii alshaafieii (almutawafaa: 558hi) almuhaqiqi: qasim muhamad alnuwri alnaashir: dar alminhaj - jidat altabeatu: al'uwlaa, 1421 ha- 2000 mi.
21.  altaj wal'iiklil limkhtasir khalil; muhamad bin yusif bin 'abi alqasim "'abu eabd allah"; dar alfikr - bayrut; t 2- 1398h.
22.  altabasrat almualafa: eali bin muhamad alrabei, 'abu alhasan, almaeruf biallakhmay tahqiqu: 'ahmad eabd alkarim najib alnaashir: wizarat al'awqaf walshuwuwn al'iislamiati, qatar altabeatu: al'uwlaa, 1432 h
23.  tabiin alhaqayiq sharh kanz aldaqayiqi; fakhr aldiyn euthman bin ealiin alziylei alhanafii; dar alkutub al'iislamii - alqahirati; t 1313hi.
24.  altajrid, almualafa: 'ahmad bin muhamad bin 'ahmad bin jaefar bin hamdan alqaduriu almuhaqiqu: markaz aldirasat alfiqhiat walaiqtisadiati, alnaashir: dar alsalam - alqahirat altabeatu: althaaniatu, 1427 hu
25.  tahifat almuhtaj fi sharh alminhaji; 'ahmad bin muhamad bin hajari; almaktabat altijariat alkubraa bimasri; eam alnashri: 1357 hi - 1983 mi; mae hashiat al'iimam eabd alhamid alsharwani; yalih hashit al'iimam 'ahmad bin qasim aleabaadi.
26.  altashrie aljinayiyu al'iislamiu mqarnaan bialqanun alwadeii almualafi: eabd alqadir eawdat alnaashir: dar alkatib alearabii, bayrut eadad al'ajza'i: 2
27.  altaerifat almualafu: eali bin muhamad bin ealiin alzayn alsharif aljirjani, almuhaqaqi: jamaeat min aleulama' bi'iishraf dar alkutub aleilmiat -lubnan altabeati: 1- 1403h.
28.  altahdhib fi aikhtisar almudawanat almualafa: khalf bin 'abi alqasim muhamad, 'abu saeid almaliki dirasat watahqiqu: alduktur muhamad al'amin wuld muhamad salim bin alshaykh alnaashir: dar albuhuth lildirasat al'iislamiat wa'iihya' altarathi, dubaya altabeatu: al'uwlaa, 1423 h
29.  altahdhib fi fiqh al'iimam alshaafieiu almualafi: muhyi alsanat, 'abu muhamad alhusayn bin maseud bin muhamad bin alfaraa' albaghawi alshaafieii almuhaqaqa: eadil 'ahmad eabd almawjudi, eali muhamad mueawad alnaashir: dar alkutub aleilmiat altabeati: al'uwlaa, 1418 hi - 1997 m
30.  althiqat almualafi: muhamad bin hibaan bin 'ahmad bin hibaan bin mueadh bin maebda, altamimi, 'abu hatim, aldaarmi, albusty (almutawafaa: 354hi) tabe bi'iieanati: wizarat almaearif lilhukumat alealiat alhindiat bihaydar abad aldukn alhind altabeata: al'uwlaa, 1393 hu‍
31.  jawahir al'iiklil sharh mukhtasar khalil; salih al'azhari; tahqiqu: muhamad eabd aleaziz alkhalidi; dar alkutub aleilmiat - bayrut; altabeat al'uwlaa- 1997m.
32.  hashiat aibn eabidin (hashiat radi almukhtar ealaa alduri almukhtar sharh tanwir al'absari); abn eabdin; dar alfikri- bayrut; 1421hi.
33.  hashiat aldasuqi ealaa alsharh alkabira; muhamad earafah aldisuwqi; tahqiqu: muhamad ealish; dar alfikr - bayrut.
34.  hashit alramli mae kitab 'asnaa almatalib fi sharh rawd altaalib almualifi: zakariaa bin muhamad bin zakariaa al'ansari, zayn aldiyn 'abu yahyaa alsuniki alnaashir: dar alkitaab al'iislamii.
35.  hashiat altahtawi ealaa maraqi alfalaah sharh nur al'iidah almualafa: 'ahmad bin muhamad bin 'iismaeil altahatawii alhanafii - tuufiy 1231 hu almuhaqiqa: muhamad eabd aleaziz alkhalidi alnaashir: dar alkutub aleilmiat bayrut - lubnan altabeata: altabeat al'uwlaa 1418h -
36.  hashit allbbadi ealaa nayl almarib almualafa: eabd alghani bin yasin bin mahmud bin yasin bin tah bin 'ahmad alllabady alnaabulsi alhanbali, tahqiq wataeliqi: alduktur muhamad sulayman al'ashqar alnaashir: dar albashayir al'islamyt lltbaeat walnshr waltwazye, bayrwt - lubnan altabeata: al'uwlaa, 1419 hu
37.  alhawy alkabir fi fiqh madhhab al'iimam alshaafieii (shrh mukhtasar almazni); eali bin muhamad almawardi albasari alshaafieayi; tahqiqa: eali mueawad - eadil eabd almawjudi; dar alkutub aleilmiat - bayrut; ta1- 1419h.
38.  haliat aleulama' fi maerifat madhahib alfuqaha' almualafi: muhamad bin 'ahmad bin alhusayn bin eumra, 'abu bakr alshaashi alqufaal alfarqy, almulaqab fakhr al'iislami, almustazhiri alshaafieii, almuhaqaqa: da. yasin 'ahmad 'iibrahim diradkat alnaashir: muasasat alrisalat / dar al'arqam - bayrut / eamaan altabeatu: al'uwlaa, 1980m .
39.  darar alhukaam fi sharh majalat al'ahkam almualafi: eali haydar khawajih 'amin 'afandi taeribi: fahmi alhusayni alnaashir: dar aljil altabeata: al'uwlaa, 1411h - 1991m
40.  daqayiq 'uwli alnahaa lisharh almuntahaa almaeruf bisharh muntahaa al'iiradat almualafi: mansur bin yunis bin salah aldiyn abn hasan bin 'iidris albahutaa alhunbulaa (almutawafaa: 1051hi) alnaashir: ealam alkutub altabeati: al'uwlaa, 1414hi - 1993m
41.  dalil altaalib linayl almatalib almualafi: marei bin yusif bin 'abaa bakr bin 'ahmad alkarmaa almaqdisii alhunbulaa (almutawafaa: 1033hi) almuhaqiqi: 'abu qutaybat nazar muhamad alfaryabi alnaashir: dar tiibat lilnashr waltawziei, alriyad altabeati: al'uwlaa, 1425h
42.  aldhakhirat almualafi: shihab aldiyn 'ahmad bin 'iidris bin eabd alwal'iimam maliki alshahir bialqurafi alnaashir: dar algharb al'iislami- bayrut altabeatu: al'uwlaa, t 1994m.

43. rudat altaalibin waeumdat almufatin almualafu: 'abu zakariaa muhyi aldiyn alnawawii tahqiqu: zuhayr alshaawish almaktab al'iislamia, bayrut- altabeatu: 3, 1412h / 1991m.
44.  sunan aibn majata; muhamad bin yazid 'abu eabdallah alqazwini; tahqiqu: muhamad fuad eabd albaqi; alnaashir: dar alfikr - bayrut.
45.  sinan 'abi dawud; sulayman bin al'asheath "'abu dawud" alsajistaniu al'azdi; tahqiqu: muhamad muhyi aldiyn eabd alhamidi; dar alfikr - lubnan.
46.  sunan altirmidhi; muhamad bin eisaa 'abu eisaa altirmidhiu alsilmi; tahqiqu: 'ahmad muhamad shakir wakhrun; dar 'iihya' alturath alearabii - bayrut.
47.  alsunan alkubraa؛ 'ahmad bin shueayb "'abu eabd alrahman" alnasayiyi; tahqiqu: da.eabd alghafar albindari; sayid hasan; dar alkutub aleilmiat - bayrut; altabeat 1; 1411h.
48.  alsiyasat alshareiat almualafu: taqi aldiyn 'abu aleabaas 'ahmad bin eabd alhalim bin eabd alsalam bin eabd allah bin 'abi alqasim bin muhamad aibn taymiat alharaanii alhanbali aldimashqi alnaashir: wizarat alshuyuwn al'iislamiat wal'awqaf waldaewat wal'iirshad - almamlakat alearabiat alsaeudiat altabeatu: al'uwlaa, 1418h
49.  sharh alzarkashiu ealaa mukhtasar alkharqi; shams aldiyn 'abi eabd allah muhamad alzarkashi alhanbali; tahqiqu: eabd almuneim 'iibrahim; dar alkutub aleilmiat - lubnan; 1423h.
50.  alsharh alsaghir; 'abu albarakat 'ahmad bin muhamad aldirdir; mae hashiat alsaawi bilughat alsaalik li'aqrab almasalik almaerufi; dar almaearifi.
51.  alsharh alkabir ealaa matn almuqanie almualafi: eabd alrahman bin muhamad bin 'ahmad bin qudamat almaqdisii alhanbalii, nashara: dar alkitaab alearabii lilnashr waltawzie
52.  alsharh alkabir lildirdir; 'abu albarakat sidi 'ahmad aldirdir; tahqiqu: muhamad ealaysh alsharha; dar alnashri: dar alfikr - bayrut.
53.  sharh fath alqadir ealaa alhidayat sharh bidayat almubtadi; muhamad bin eabd alwahid kamal aldiyn aibn alhumaam - 'ahmad qadi zadahu; almuhaqiqa: eabd alrazaaq almahdi; dar alkutub aleilmiati; alnashr: 1424 - 2003m.
54.  sharh mukhtasar khalil lilkharashii almualafi: muhamad bin eabd allah alkharshi almaliki 'abu eabd allah alnaashir: dar alfikr liltibaeat - bayrut altabeatu: bidun tabeatin, wabihamishih hashiat aleadwi.
55.  alsihah taj allughat wasihah alearabiat almualafu: 'abu nasr 'iismaeil bin hamaad aljawhari tahqiqu: 'ahmad eabd alghafur eataar alnaashir: dar aleilm lilmalayin - bayrut altabeatu: 4
56.  sahih albukharii (aljamie alsahihu); muhamad bin 'iismaeil "'abu eabdallah" albukhariu aljaeafi; tahqiqu: mustafaa dib albugha; alnaashir: dar aibn kathir - bayrut; altabeat althaalithatu; 1407h
57.  sahih muslmin; muslim bin alhajaaj "'abu alhusayni" alqushayriu alnaysaburi; tahqiqu: muhamad fuaad eabd albaqi; dar 'iihya' alturath alearabii - bayrut.
58.  aleinayat sharh alhidayati; muhamad bin mahmud; aibn alshaykh shams aldiyn aibn alshaykh jamal aldiyn alruwmiu albabirti; dar alfikri, ta1.
59.  euyun almasayil almualafu: 'abu muhamad eabd alwahaab bin eali bin nasr althaelabii albaghdadii alwal'iimam maliki dirasat watahqiqu: eali mhmmad 'iibrahim buruybat alnaashir: dar aibn hazam liltibaeat walnashr waltawzie, bayrut - lubnan altabeata: al'uwlaa, 1430 hi - 2009 m
60.  fatawaa shaykh al'iislam abn taymiata; talifi: 'ahmad eabd alhalim bin taymiat alharaanii 'abu aleabaasi; tahqiqu: eabd alrahman bin muhamad bin qasimi; altabeat althaaniatu; alnaashir: maktabat abn taymiatin.
61.  fath albari sharh sahih albukharii almualafa: 'ahmad bin ealiin bin hajar 'abu alfadl aleasqalaniu alshaafieiu alnaashir: dar almaerifat - bayrut, 1379.
62.  fath alqidir: muhamad bin ealii bin muhamad bin eabd allh alshuwkanii alyamaniu, alnaashir: dar abn kathirin, dar alkalm altayib - dimashqa, bayrut altabeata: al'uwlaa - 1414 hu.
63.  fath alwahaab bisharh manhaj altulaabi; zakariaa bin muhamad bin 'ahmad al'ansari "'abu yahyaa"; dar alkutub aleilmiat - bayrut; altabeat 1; 1418hi.
64.  alfurue wamaeah tashih alfuruea, eali almirdawi; muhamad bin muflah bin muhamad bin mufraji; 'abu eabd allah; shams aldiyn almuqdasii thuma alsaalihiu alhunbali; almuhaqiqa: eabd allah alturki; muasasat alrisalati; altabeatu: 1- 1424 hi - 2003 mi.
65.  falsafat aleuqubat fi al'iislami, 'abu zahrata, nashra: jamieat alduwal alearabiati, maehad aldirasat alearabiat alealiati,, ta1- 2007
66.  alfawakih aldawani ealaa risalat abn 'abi zayd alqayrawani; 'ahmad bin ghunim alnafrawii almaliki; dar alfikr - bayrut- 1415hi.
67.  qawaeid al'ahkam fi masalih al'anam almualafu: 'abu muhamad eiz aldiyn eabd aleaziz bin eabd alsalam bin 'abi alqasim bin alhasan alsulami aldimashqi, rajaeah waealaq ealayhi: tah eabd alrawuwf saed alnaashir: maktabat alkuliyaat al'azhariat - alqahira (wasuwwratuha dawr eidat mithla: dar alkutub aleilmiat - bayrut, wadar 'am alquraa - alqahirati) tabeatun: jadidat madbutat munaqahatun, 1414 hu - 1991
68.  alqawanin alfiqhiat almualafu: 'abu alqasima, muhamad bin 'ahmad bin muhamad bin eabd allah, abn jiziy alkalbi algharnati, almaktabat alshaamilati.
69.  alkafi fi fiqh al'iimam 'ahmadu; 'abu muhamad muafaq aldiyn eabd allah bin qudamat almaqdasii thuma aldimashqiu alhanbali; dar alkutub aleilmiati; altabeati: al'uwlaa; 1414 hi - 1994 mi.
70.   kshaf alqinae ean matn al'iiqnaei; mansur bin yunis albuhuti; tahqiqu: hilal mustafaa hilal; dar alfikri- bayrut- 1402h.
71.  lisan alearbi; muhamad bin makram bin manzur almasriu; altabeat al'uwlaa; dar sad - bayrut.
72.  almubdie fi sharh almuqanaea; 'iibrahim bin muhamad abn muflihi; 'abu 'iishaqa; burhan aldiyn; dar alkutub aleilmiati; bayrut - lubnan; altabeati: 1- 1418 hi - 1997 mi.
73.  alimabsuta; shams aldiyn alsarakhisi; tahqiqu: muhamad asmaeili; dar alkutub aleilmiat - bayrut; altabeat al'uwlaa; 1424hi.
74.  mujamae alzawayid wamanbae alfawayidi; eali bin 'abi bakr alhaythami; alnaashir: dar alrayaan liltarathi/‏dar alkutaab alearabiu - alqahiratu, bayrut; 1407h.
76.  almuhalaa bialathar almualafi: 'abu muhamad eali bin 'ahmad bin saeid bin hazm al'andalasi alqurtubii alzaahiriu dar alfikr - bayrut altabeatu: bidun tabeati, almaktabat alshaamilati.
77.  almudawanat almualafu: wal'iimam malik bin 'anas bin wal'iimam malik bin eamir al'asbahii almadaniu alnaashir: dar alkutub aleilmiat altabeatu: al'uwlaa، 1415
78.  maratib al'iijmae fi aleibadat walmueamalat walaietiqadati, almualaf : 'abu muhamad eali bin 'ahmad bin saeid bin hazm al'andalusi alqurtubii alzaahirii, alnaashir : dar alkutub aleilmiat - bayrut
79.  alimustadrak ealaa alsahihayn almualafi: 'abu eabd allah alhakim muhamad bin eabd allah bin muhamad bin nueym bin alhakam aldabiu alnaysaburiu almaeruf biaibn albaye, tahqiqu: mustafaa eabd alqadir eata alnaashir: dar alkutub aleilmiat - bayrut altabeatu: al'uwlaa، 1411 .
80.  msnid al'iimam 'ahmad bin hanbul; 'abu eabd allah 'ahmad bin muhamad bin hanbal bin hilal bin 'asad alshiybani; almuhaqaqi: shueayb al'arnawuwt - eadil murshid; wakhrin; 'iishrafi: d eabd allah bin eabd almuhsin alturki; alnaashir: muasasat alrisalati; altabeatu: al'uwlaa; 1421 hi - 2001 mi.
81.  almisbah almunir fi gharayb alsharh alkabira; 'ahmad bin muhamad bin eali alfiuwmi thuma alhamawy; 'abu aleabaas; alnaashir: almaktabat aleilmiatu; bayrut.
82.  matalib 'uwli alnahaa fi sharh ghayat almuntahaa; mustafaa bin saed alsuyuti; almaktab al'iislamii; altabeati: 2; 1415h - 1994m.
83.  almutalae ealaa 'alfaz almuqanae almualafi: muhamad bin 'abi alfath bin 'abi alfadl albaeli, 'abu eabd allah, shams aldiyn almuhaqaqi: mahmud al'arnawuwt wayasin mahmud alkhatib alnaashir: maktabat alsawadi liltawzie altabeati: altabeat al'uwlaa 1423h - 2003 mi.
84.  maejam maqayis allughat almualafi: 'ahmad bin faris bin zakariaa alqazwinii alraazi, almuhaqaqa: eabd alsalam muhamad harun alnaashir: dar alfikr eam alnashri: 1399h
85.  mighni almuhtaj 'iilaa maerifat maeani 'alfaz alminhaji, shams aldiyni, muhamad bn 'ahmad alkhatib alshirbinii alshaafieii, dar alkutub aleilmiat altabeati: 1, 1415hi - 1994m .
86.  almughaniy liabn qadamat; 'abu muhamad muafaq aldiyn eabd allh bin 'ahmad bin muhamad bin qudamat almaqdasii thuma aldimashqiu alhanbaliu; alshahir biabn qudamat almaqdisi; alnaashir: maktabat alqahirati; tarikh alnashr: 1388h - 1968m
87.  almuqanie fi fiqh al'iimam 'ahmad bin hanbal alshaybani rahimah allah taealaa almualafa: muafaq aldiyn 'abu muhamad eabd allah bin 'ahmad bin muhamad bin qudamat almaqdisi alnaashir: maktabat alsawadi liltawziei, jidat - almamlakat alearabiat alsaeudiat altabeatu: al'uwlaa
88.  almumtae fi sharh almuqanae tasnifa: zayn aldiyn almunajja bin euthman bin 'asead aibn almanjaa altanukhii alhanbalii dirasatan watahqiqu: eabd almalik bin eabd allah bin dahiish altabeata: althaalithata, 1424 hu
89.  almuntaqaa sharh almuataa almualafi: 'abu alwalid sulayman albaji al'andalusii alnaashir: matbaeat alsaeadati, altabeatu: al'uwlaa, 1332 h
90.  mnah aljalil sharh mukhtasar khalil; muhamad ealish; 'abu eabd allah almaliki; dar alfikr - bayrut; tarikh alnashr: 1409h/1989m.
91.  alminhaj sharh sahih muslim bin alhajaaj almualafu: 'abu zakariaa muhyi aldiyn yahyaa bin sharaf alnawawiu alnaashir: dar 'iihya' alturath alearabii - bayrut altabeata: althaaniatu, 1392.
92.  almuhadhab fi fiqh al'iimam alshaafieiu almualafu: 'abu ashaq 'iibrahim bin eali bin yusif alshiyrazi alnaashir: dar alkutub aleilmia
93. almuafaqati: 'iibrahim bin musaa bin muhamad allakhmi algharnatiu alshahir bialshaatibii, almuhaqaqi: 'abu eubaydat mashhur bin hasan al silman: dar aibn eafaan altabeata: altabeat 1- 1417hi. 94. mawahib aljalil fi sharh mukhtasar khalil; shams aldiyn 'abu eabd allah muhamad bin muhamadi; almaeruf bialhitab almaliki; dar alfikri; altabeati: 3; 1412h - 1992m. 95. nihayat almuhtaj 'iilaa sharh alminhaji; shams aldiyn muhamad bin 'abi aleabaas 'ahmad bin hamzat shihab aldiyn alramli; alnaashir: dar alfikri; bayrut; altabeati: t 'akhirat - 1404h/1984m. 96. nayl almarib bsharh dalil alttalib, eabd alqadir bin eumar bin 'abi taghlib bin salim altaghalabi alshshaybany, almuhaqiqi: alduktur muhamad sulyman al'ashqara, maktabat alfalahi, alkuayt altabeati: 1, 1403 hu
97.  alhidayat fi sharh bidayat almubtadi almualafi: eali bin 'abi bakr alfirghani almirghinani, 'abu alhasan burhan aldiyn almuhaqaqi: talal yusif alnaashir: dar ahya' alturath alearabii - bayrut.