الدوافع الغرَّاء لكتابة المحدثين روايات الثقات والضعفاء

المؤلف

مدرس الحديث وعلومه، كلية أصول الدين والدعوة بالمنصورة، جامعة الأزهر

المستخلص

الملخص:
اعتمد الباحث في كتابة هذا البحث على عدة مناهج علمية، كالمنهج الاستقرائي التحليلي، والمنهج الوصفي الاستنباطي، والمنهج التوثيقي التاريخي، من أجل الوصول إلى رؤية شاملة وعامة، فقام بالبحث في كل ما يتعلق بجزئيات هذا الموضوع، وعرض المعلومات عرضا مرتبًا، مع توثيق وتحليل كلام الأئمة وتوجيهه، واستنباط ما يسهم في تجديد علم الحديث الشريف، وحسن فهمه، والدفاع عن السنة، وعن أئمة الحديث؛ فكانت هذه المباحث الثلاثة، وتوصل الباحث إلى الأسباب الحقيقية لرواية المحدثين عن الثقات والضعفاء، وأنها تدل على علمهم وشدة احتياطهم وسعة الأفق العلمي لديهم. وأوصي الباحث بالتوسع في دراسة كتب المحدثين الكبار، وعمل البحوث المتخصصة التي تتناول مذاهبهم وتوضيحها، والدفاع عنهم، ودراسة مسألة الاستعمال، وعمل دراسة أخرى موسعة في استفادة المحدثين من أحاديث الضعفاء على اختلاف مراتبهم. كُتبت السنة النبوية منذ عصر سيدنا رسول الله بأمره، والأحاديث التي أمرت بكتابتها أقوى من تلك التي نهت عنها، واستجاب الصحابة – رضوان الله عنهم- لهذا الأمر النبوي بالكتابة والتبليغ عنه، فمن ثم كتبت السنة شيئًا فشيئًا حتى تم تدوينها الرسمي بأمر الخليفة عمر بن عبد العزيز رحمه الله تعالى، وقام العلماء بكتابة المصنفات المتعددة للحفاظ على السنة النبوية الشريفة
 

الكلمات الرئيسية

الموضوعات الرئيسية


 
• alquran alkarim.
• al'iikmal fi dhikr man lah riwayat fi musnad al'iimam 'ahmad min alrijal siwaa man dhakir fi tahdhib alkamali, lishams aldiyn 'abi almahasin muhamad bin eali bin alhasan aldimashqii alshaafieii (almutawafaa: 765h), haqaqah wawathaqahu: da. eabd almueti 'amin qileiji, alnaashir: manshurat jamieat aldirasat al'iislamiati, karatshi - bakistan.
• tarikh abn mueayan (riwayat euthman aldaarmi), li'abi zakariaa yahyaa bin muein bin eawn almirii bialwala'i, albaghdadii (almutawafaa: 233h), almuhaqiqi: du. 'ahmad muhamad nur sif, alnaashir: dar almamun lilturath - dimashqa.
• tarikh aibn mueayn  riwayat aldawri, li'abi zakariaa yahyaa bin mueayn ( t 233 ha ), alnaashir: markaz albuhuth aleilmii wa'iihya' alturath al'iislamii  makat almukaramati, altabeatu: al'uwlaa 1399h  1979m, tahqiqu: du: 'ahmad muhamad nur sif.
• tarikh al'iislam wawafayat almashahir wal'aelami, lishams aldiyn 'abi eabd allah muhamad bin 'ahmad euthman bin qaymaz aldhahabii ( t 748 ha), dar alnashr : dar alkutab alearabii, makan alnashr : bayrut / lubnan , altabeatu: al'uwlaa, 1407h  1987m , tahqiq : d . eumar eabd alsalam tadamuri.
• tarikh baghdada, li'abi bakr 'ahmad bin ealii bin thabit alkhatib albaghdadi ( t 463 hi ) , dar alnashri: dar alkutub aleilmiat  bayrut.
• altaarikh alkabiri, li'abi eabd allah muhamad bin 'iismaeil bin 'iibrahim albukhari ( t 256 hi ) , dar alnashri: dar alfikri, tahqiq : alsayid hashim alnndwi.
• tarikh madinat dimashqa, li'abi alqasim ealiin bin alhasan bin hibat allh bin easakir alddimashqi ( t 571 hu), dar alnashri: dar alfikr  bayrut , 1995m , tahqiq : muhibi aldiyn 'abi saeid eumar bin gharamat aleamri.
• tadrib alraawy fi sharh taqrib alnawawi, lilhafiz 'abi alfadl jalal aldiyn eabd alrahman bin 'abi bakr alssuyuti ( t 911 hi ) , dar alnashri: maktabat alriyad alhadithat , tahqiq :eabd alwahaab eabd allatif .
• tadhkirat alhifazi, limuhamad bin 'ahmad bin euthman aldhahabii ( t 748 ha) , dar alnashri: dar alkutub aleilmiat bayrut / lubnan, altabeat : al'uwlaa 1419h  1998m , dirasat watahqiqu: zakaria eumayrat.
• taqrib altahdhib, li'abi alfadl 'ahmad bin ealii bin hajar aleasqalani ( t 852 ha ), dar alnashri: dar alkutub aleilmiat  bayrut  lubnan , altabeat : althaaniat 1415h  1995m, tahqiq : mustafaa eabd alqadir.
• altamyiazi, limuslim bin alhajaaj 'abi alhasan alqushayrii alnaysaburii (almutawafaa: 261hi), almuhaqiqi: du. muhamad mustafaa al'aezami, alnaashir: maktabat alkawthar - almurabae - alsaeudiatu, altabeatu: althaalithatu, 1410hi.
• altankil bima fi tanib alkuthari min al'abatili, lieabd alrahman bin yahyaa bin eali bin muhamad almuealimi alyamani (almutawafaa: 1386h), mae takhrijat wataeliqati: muhamad nasir aldiyn al'albanii - zuhayr alshaawish - eabd alrazaaq hamzat, alnaashir: almaktab al'iislamia, altabeati: althaaniati, 1406 hi - 1986 mi.
• tahdhib alathar watafsil althaabit ean rasul allah min al'akhbari, limuhamad bin jarir bin yazid bin kathir alamli, 'abi jaefar altabari (almutawafaa: 310h), almuhaqiqi: mahmud muhamad shakir, alnaashir: matbaeat almadanii - alqahira.
• tahdhib altahdhib , li'abi alfadl 'ahmad bin ealii bin hajar aleasqalani ( t 852 hi ) , dar alnashru: dar alfikr  bayrut, altabeata: al'uwlaa 1404h  1984m .
• tahdhib alkamal fi 'asma' alrajal, li'abi alhajaaj yusif bin eabd alrahman almizzi ( t 742 hi ) dar alnashri: muasasat alrisalat  bayrut, altabeat : al'uwlaa 1400h  1980m, tahqiqu: d . bashaar eawad maerufi.
• althiqati, li'abi hatim muhamad bin hibban bin 'ahmad alttamimi albusti ( t 354 ha ), dar alnashri: dar alfikr  bayrut , altabeat : al'uwlaa 1395h  1975m, tahqiqi: alsayid sharaf aldiyn 'ahmadu.
• jamie bayan aleilm wafadluhu, liusuf bin eabd allah abn eabd albiri (almutawafaa: 463hi), tahqiqu: 'abi al'ashbal alzuhiri, alnaashir: dar abn aljuzi, almamlakat alearabiat alsueudiati, altabeat al'uwlaa, 1414 hi - 1994m.
• jamie altahsil fi 'ahkam almarasili, li'abi saeid salah aldiyn khalil bin kaykaladi bin eabd allah alealayiy alddimashqi ( t 761 hi ) , dar alnashr : ealim alkutub  bayrut , altabeat : althaaniat 1407h  1986m , tahqiq : hamdi eabd almajid alsalafi .
• aljamie li'akhlaq alraawi wadab alsaamiei, li'abi bakr 'ahmad bin ealii bin thabiti, alkhatib albaghdadii (almutawafaa: 463hi), almuhaqiqi: du. mahmud altahaani, alnaashir: maktabat almaearif - alrayad. juz'ani.
• aljurh waltaedili, li'abi muhamad eabd alrahman bin 'abi hatim muhamad bin 'iidris alrrazi ( t 327 hi ) , dar alnashr : dar 'iihya' alturath alearabii  bayrut , altabeat : al'uwlaa 1271h  1952m .
• alhadith walmuhdithuna, limuhamad muhamad 'abi zahw rahimah allahu, alnaashir: dar alfikr alearabii, altabeatu: alqahirat fi 2 min jumadaa althaaniat 1378hu, eadad al'ajza'i: 1.
• alduea', lisulayman bin 'ahmad bin 'ayuwb bin mutayr allakhmi alshaami, 'abi alqasim altabaranii (almutawafaa: 360h), almuhaqiqi: mustafaa eabd alqadir eata, alnaashir: dar alkutub aleilmiat - bayrut, altabeatu: al'uwlaa, 1413hi.
• dhkar man yaetamid qawlah fi aljurh waltaedil (matbue dimn kitab <<'arbae rasayil fi eulum alhudith>>, lishams aldiyn 'abi eabd allah muhamad bin 'ahmad bin euthman bin qaymaz aldhahabi (almutawafaa: 748h), almuhaqiq: eabd alfataah 'abu ghudata, alnaashir: dar albashayir - bayrut, altabeata: alraabieati, 1410hi, 1990m.
• risalat 'abi dawud 'iilaa 'ahl makat waghayrihim fi wasf sununihi, li'abi dawud sulayman bin al'asheath bin 'iishaq al'azdi alssijistany (almutawafaa: 275h), almuhaqaqi: muhamad alsabaghi, alnaashir: dar alearabiat - bayrut.
• risalat fi fadl al'akhbar washarh madhahib 'ahl aluathar wahaqiqat alsinan, li'abi eabd allah muhamad bin 'iishaq bin muhamad bin yahyaa bin mandah aleabdi (almutawafaa: 395h), almuhaqiq: eabd alrahman eabd aljabaar alfirywayy, alnaashir: dar almuslim - alrayad, altabeati: al'uwlaa, 1414hi.
• alrisalatu, lilshaafieii, 'abi eabd allh muhamad bin 'iidris bin aleabaasi, almatlabii alqurashii almakiyi (almutawafaa: 204hi), almuhaqiqi: 'ahmad shakiri, alnaashir: maktabah alhalbi, masr.
• rafe almalam ean al'ayimat al'aelami, litaqi aldiyn 'abi aleabas 'ahmad bin eabd alhalim , alriyad - almamlakat alearabiat alsueudiati, eam alnashri: 1403 hi - 1983 mi.
• alrafe waltakmil fi aljurh waltaedili, limuhamad eabd alhayi bin muhamad eabd alhalim al'ansariu alliknawi alhindi, 'abi alhasanat (almutawafaa: 1304h), almuhaqiq: eabd alfataah 'abu ghudata, alnaashir: maktab almatbueat al'iislamiat - halb, altabeatu: althaalithatu, 1407hi.
• sunan altirmidhi, li'abi eisaa muhamad bin eisaa alttirmidhi (t 279 ha ), dar alnashri: dar 'iihya' alturath alearabii bayrut, tahqiq : 'ahmad muhamad shakir wakhrun .
• sunan alnnasayiy (almujtabaa), li'abi eabd alrahman 'ahmad bin shueayb alnnasayiy ( t 303 ha ), dar alnashra: maktab almatbueat al'iislamiat  halab , althaaniat 1406h  1986m , tahqiq : eabd alfataah 'abu ghuda.
• alsanat qabl altadwini, limuhamad eajaj bin muhamad tamim bin salih bin eabd allah alkhatib, alnaashir: dar alfikr liltibaeat walnashr waltawzie, bayrut - lubnan, altabeati: althaalithati, 1400 hi - 1980 m
• suwaalat aibn 'abi shaybat li'abi alhasan eali bin eabd allh bin jaefar almadinii t 234 ha, tahqiqu: muafaq eabd allah eabd alqadir, maktabat almaearif - alrayad, t / al'uwlaa, 1404 h.
• suwaalat 'abi eubayd alajri 'aba dawud alsijistaniu fi aljurh waltaedili, li'abi dawud sulayman bin al'asheath alssijistany (almutawafaa: 275h), almuhaqaqi: muhamad eali qasim aleamri, alnaashir: eimadat albahth aleilmii bialjamieat al'iislamiati, almadinat almunawarati, almamlakat alearabiat alsaeudiati.
• suwaalat aibn aljunid li'abi zakariaa yahyaa bin mueayn bin eawn albaghdadi (almutawafaa: 233hi), almuhaqiqi: 'ahmad muhamad nur sif, dar alnashra: maktabat aldaar - almadinat almunawarati.
• sharh ealal altirmidhi, lizayn aldiyn eabd alrahman bin 'ahmadu, alsalamy, albaghdadi, thuma aldimashqi, alhanbali (almutawafaa: 795h), almuhaqiqi: alduktur humam eabd alrahim saeid, alnaashir: maktabat almanar - alzarqa' - al'urdunu, altabeati: al'uwlaa, 1407h - 1987m.
• shih albukhari, li'abi eabd allah muhamad bin 'iismaeil albukhari aljuefi ( t 256 hi ) , dar alnashri: dar abn kathir  bayrut , altabeat : althaalithat 1407hi  1987m , tahqiq : du. mustafaa dib albugha.
• shih muslim, li'abi alhusayn muslim bin alhajjaj alqushayri alnnaysaburi ( t 261 hu), dar alnashri: dar 'iihya' alturath alearabii  bayrut , tahqiq : muhamad fuad eabd albaqi.
• shih muslim bisharh alnawawii, li'abi zakariaa yahyaa bin sharaf bin murri alnnawawi ( t 676 ha ), dar alnashr : dar 'iihya' alturath alearabii  bayrut , altabeat : althaaniat 1392h.
• ktab aldueafa'i, lil'iimam muhamad bin 'iismaeil bin 'iibrahim albukhari, 'abi eabd allah (almutawafaa: 256hi), almuhaqiqi: 'abu eabd alllh 'ahmad bin 'iibrahim bin 'abi aleaynayni, alnaashir: maktabat aibn eabaas, altabeatu: al'uwlaa 1426h/2005mi.
• aldueafa' alkabiru, li'abi jaefar muhamad bin eamriw bin musaa aleuqayli (t 322 hi ) , dar alnashr : dar almaktabat aleilmiat  bayrut , altabeat : al'uwlaa 1404h  1984m , tahqiq : eabd almueti 'amin qileiji.
• aldueafa' wa'ajwibat 'abi zareat alraazi ealaa sualat albirdhey, lieubid allah bin eabd alkarim bin yazid alraazi, 'abi zarea (t 264h), alnaashir: aljamieat al'iislamiat  almadinat almunawarati, altabeata: al'uwlaa 1402h  1982ma, almuhaqiqu: du. saed alhashimi.
• aldueafa' walmatrukun, li'abi eabd alrahman 'ahmad bin shueayb alnasayiyi ( t 303 ha) , alnaashir : dar muasasat alkutub althaqafiat  bayrut  altabeat : al'uwlaa 1405 hi , 1985m, almuhaqiq : buran aldanawi, wakamal yusif alhut.
• altabaqat alkubraa, li'abi eabd allah muhamad bin saed bin manie albasri ( t 230 hi ) , dar alnashr : dar sadir  bayrut , altabeat : al'uwlaa 1968m , aljamieatu, almuhaqiqu: 'iihsan eabaas .
• tabaqat almudalisin (taerif 'ahl altaqdis bimaratib almusufun bialtadlisi), li'abi alfadl 'ahmad bin ealii bin hajar aleasqalani alshshafiei ( t 852 ha ), dar alnashra: maktabat almanar  eamaan , altabeat : al'uwlaa 1403h 1983m , tahqiq : d . easim bin eabd allah alqiryuti.
• ealal altirmidhii alkabiri, limuhamad bin eisaa bin sawrt bin musaa bin aldahaki, altirmidhi, 'abi eisaa (almutawafaa: 279hi), ratabah ealaa kutub aljamiei: 'abu talib alqadi, almuhaqaqa: subhi alsaamaraayiy, 'abu almaeati alnuwri, mahmud khalil alsaeidi, alnaashir: ealim alkatab, maktabat alnahdat alearabiat - bayrut, altabeatu: al'uwlaa, 1409hi.
• aleilal walsuwalati, lieali bin eabd allah bin jaefar almadini, albasariu, 'abi alhasan (almutawafaa: 234hi), almuhaqaqi: muhamad mustafaa al'aezami, alnaashiru: almaktab al'iislamiu - bayrut, altabeatu: althaaniatu, 1980m.
• aleilal wamaerifat alrajal, li'abi eabd allah 'ahmad bin muhamad hanbal alshshaybani (t 241 ha ), ta: almaktab al'iislamii, dar alkhani  bayrut, alriyad  1408h  1988m , altabeatu: al'uwlaa, tahqiq : wasiu allah bin muhamad eabaas .
• aleilal walsuwalat min kalam 'ahmad bin hanbal fi eilal alhadith wamaerifat alrajal, li'abi eabd allah 'ahmad bin muhamad bin hanbal bin hilal bin 'asad alshaybani (almutawafaa: 241h), almuhaqiqi: subhi albadri alsaamaraayiy, alnaashir: maktabat almaearif - alrayad, altabeati: al'uwlaa, 1409hi.
• fath albari sharh sahih albukhari, li'abi alfadl 'ahmad bin ealiin bin hajar aleasqalani (t 852 hu), dar alnashri: dar almaerifat  bayrut, tahqiqu: muhibi aldiyn alkhatib .
• alkashif fi maerifat man lah riwayat fi alkutub alsitati, lishams aldiyn 'abi eabd allah muhamad bin 'ahmad bin euthman aldhahabii ( t 748 hi ) , dar alnashr : dar alqiblat lilthaqafat al'iislamiat , muasasat eulum alquran  jidat , altabeatu: al'uwlaa 1413h  1992m , tahqiq : muhamad eawama.
• alkamil fi altaarikhi, lieizi aldiyn 'abu alhasan eali bin muhamad bin eabd alkarim aljazari, almaeruf biaibn al'athir (630hi) , alnaashir : dar alkutub aleilmiat  bayrut , altabeat : althaaniat 1415 hu , tahqiq : eabd allah alqadi.
• alkamil fi dueafa' alrajali, li'abi 'ahmad eabd allh bin eadi aljurjani ( t 365 hi ) , dar alnashr : dar alkutub aleilmiat  bayrut  altabeat : al'uwlaa 1418h , 1997m , tahqiq : eadil 'ahmad eabd almawjud  eali muhamad mueawad.
• alkifayat fi eilm alriwayati, li'abi bakr 'ahmad bin ealii bin thabit bin 'ahmad bin mahdii alkhatib albaghdadii (almutawafaa: 463hi), almuhaqiqi: 'abu eabd allah alsuwrqi, 'iibrahim hamdi almadani, alnaashir: almaktabat aleilmiat - almadinat almunawarati.
• alkinaa wal'asma'i, li'abi alhusayn muslim bin alhajjaj alqushayri ( t 261 hi ) , dar alnashr : aljamieat al'iislamiat  almadinat almunawarat , altabeat : al'uwlaa 1404h , tahqiq : eabd alrahim muhamad 'ahmad alqashqari.
• lisan alearabi, limuhamad bin mukram bin manzur al'afriqi almisri ( t 711 ha ), dar alnashr : dar sadir  bayrut , altabeat : al'uwlaa .
• lisan almizani, li'abi alfadl 'ahmad bin eali bin hajar aleasqalani ( t 852 hi ) , t : muasasat al'aelami lilmatbueat  bayrut , althaalithat 1406h  1986m , tahqiq : dayirat almaerif alnizamiat  alhindu.
• almutafaq walmuftaraqu, li'abi bakr 'ahmad bin ealii bin thabit alkhatib albaghdadii ( t 463 hu), alnaashir: dar alqadiri liltibaeat walnashr waltawzie  dimashq , altabeat : al'uwlaa 1417h  1997m , dirasat watahqiqu: d . muhamad sadiq aydin alhamidi.
• almajruhin min almuhdithin waldueafa' walmatrukina, li'abi hatim muhamad bin hibban albusti ( t 354 hi ) , dar alnashri: dar alwaey  halab , altabeat : al'uwlaa 1396h , tahqiq : mahmud 'iibrahim zayid.
• majmue alfatawaa, litaqi aldiyn 'abi aleabaas 'ahmad bin eabd alhalim bin taymiat alharaani (almutawafaa: 728h), almuhaqiq: eabd alrahman bin muhamad bin qasimi, alnaashir: majamae almalik fahd litibaeat almushaf alsharifi, almadinat alnabawiati, almamlakat alearabiat alsaeudiati, eam alnashri: 1416h/1995m
• almadkhal 'iilaa kitab al'iiklili, li'abi eabd allah alhakim muhamad bin eabd allah bin muhamad bin hamduih alnaysaburii almaeruf biaibn albaye (almutawafaa: 405h), almuhaqiq: du. fuad eabd almuneam, alnaashir: dar aldaewat - al'iiskandiria.
• almarasili, lieabd alrahman bin 'abi hatim muhamad bin 'iidris alraazi (t 327 ha) tahqiqu: shakar allah niemat allah qawjani - muasasat alrisalat - bayrut - t / al'uwlaa - 1397 hu.
• maerifat 'anwae eulum alhaditha, wyuerf bimuqadimat abn alsalahi, lieuthman bin eabd alrahman, 'abi eamrw, taqi aldiyn almaeruf biaibn alsalah (almutawafaa: 643hi), almuhaqiqi: nur aldiyn eatra, alnaashir: dar alfikri- suria, dar alfikr almueasir - bayrut, sanat alnashr: 1406h - 1986m.
• maerifat althiqat min rijal 'ahl aleilm walhadith wamin aldueafa' wadhakr madhahibihim wa'akhbarihim, li'abi alhasan 'ahmad bin eabd allah bin salih aleijli alkufi ( t 261 hi ) , dar alnashr : maktabat aldaar  almadinat almunawarat  alsaeudiat , altabeat : al'uwlaa 1405h  1985m , tahqiq : eabd alealim eabd aleazim albustui.
• maerifat alrijal ean yahyaa bin mueayn. wafih ean ealii bin almudini, wa'abi bakr bin 'abi shibata, wamuhamad bin eabd allah bin numir, waghayruhim/ riwayat 'ahmad bin muhamad bin alqasim bin muhriz, li'abi zakariaa yahyaa bin mueayn (almutawafaa: 233hi), almuhaqiqi: aljuz' al'awala: muhamad kamil alqasaari, alnaashir: majmae allughat alearabiat - dimashqa, altabeatu: al'uwlaa, 1405hi, 1985m.
• almaerifat waltaarikhi, li'abi yusuf yaequb bin sufyan alfasawi ( t 277 ha ), dar alnashri: dar alkutub aleilmiati bayrut  1419h  1999m , tahqiqu: khalil almansur.
• maghani al'akhyar fi sharh 'asamay rijal maeani alathar, li'abi muhamad mahmud bin 'ahmad bin musaa badr aldiyn aleaynii ( t 855 hi ) , alnaashir : dar alkutub aleilmiat  bayrut  lubnan , altabeat : al'uwlaa: 1427h  2006m , tahqiqu: muhamad hasan muhamad 'iismaeil.
• almughaniy fi aldueafa'i, lishams aldiyn muhamad bin 'ahmad bin euthman aldhahabi ( t 748 ha ), tahqiq : aldukturu/ nur aldiyn eatr .
• muejam maqayis allughati, li'ahmad bin faris bin zakaria' alqazwinii alraazi, 'abi alhusayn (almutawafaa: 395hi), almuhaqiqa: eabd alsalam muhamad harun, alnaashir: dar alfikri, eam alnashri: 1399h - 1979m.
• maejam allughat alearabiat almueasirati, lildukturu/ 'ahmad mukhtar eabd alhamid eumar (almutawafaa: 1424h), alnaashir: ealim alkutub, altabeati: al'uwlaa, 1429 hi - 2008 m
• almunhal alrawii fi mukhtasar eulum alhadith alnabawii, li'abi eabd allah, muhamad bin 'iibrahim bin saed allah bin jamaeat alkinanii alhamawii alshaafieaya, badr aldiyn (almutawafaa: 733hi), almuhaqiqi: du. muhyi aldiyn eabd alrahman ramadan, alnaashir: dar alfikr - dimashqa, altabeatu: althaaniatu, 1406.
• mizan alaietidal fi naqd alrijal, li'abi eabd allah muhamad bin 'ahmad bin euthman aldhahabii ( t 748 hi ) , dar alnashr : dar alkutub aleilmiat  bayrut , altabeat : al'uwlaa 1995m , tahqiq : alshaykh eali muhamad mueawad walshaykh eadil 'ahmad eabd almawjud .
• minhaj alsunat alnabawiat fi naqd kalam alshiyeat alqadariati, litaqi aldiyn 'abi aleabaas 'ahmad bin eabd alhalim aibn taymiat alharaani alhanbali aldimashqii (almutawafaa: 728hi), almuhaqaqa: muhamad rashad salima, alnaashir: jamieat al'iimam muhamad bin sueud al'iislamiati, altabeata: al'uwlaa, 1406 hi - 1986 m
• almuaqazat fi eilm mustalah alhadithi, lishams aldiyn 'abi eabd allh muhamad bin 'ahmad bin euthman bin qaymaz aldhahabii (almutawafaa: 748hi), aietanaa bihi: eabd alfataah 'abu ghuddt, alnaashir: maktabat almatbueat al'iislamiat bihalbi, altabeati: althaaniati, 1412 ha, eadad al'ajza'i: 1
• nazarat fi tarikh alsanati, lil'ustadh alduktur/ twfyq 'ahmad salman, tabeat jamieat al'azhar alsharif.
•           alnakt ealaa kitab aibn alsalahi, li'abi alfadl 'ahmad bin eali bin muhamad bin 'ahmad bin hajar aleasqalani (almutawafaa: 852h), almuhaqiqi: rabie bin hadi eumayr almadkhali, alnaashir: eimadat albahth aleilmii bialjamieat al'iislamiati, almadinat almunawarati, almamlakat alearabiat alsaeudiat, altabeati: al'uwlaa, 1404h/1984m.